Hungarian experiences in innovation ecosystem management from a large corporate perspective
Published: 2022, Issue 1/2022
Abstract. Although the topic of innovation ecosystems is becoming increasingly popular in both scientific and governmental and corporate decision-making circles, very few academically rigorous case studies have been produced regarding the practice of ecosystem management in Hungary to date. This study presents the experiences of ecosystem-based cooperation organised around the agricultural innovation business unit of a Hungarian large corporation with a long history, Tungsram. Within the framework of the research, 26 anonymous, semi-structured interviews were conducted with the company, as well as with state, market, and academic actors participating in the ecosystem. From the results of the qualitative investigation, it can be concluded, on the one hand, that organisational practices required for ecosystem-based cooperation in Hungary are poorly established, and the relationships between scientific actors and corporate partners are primarily characterised by mistrust. On the other hand, the research also highlights that the development of an ecosystem structure only becomes a relevant issue following a certain "maturity" of the cooperation; rather, the prerequisites for establishing stable ecosystem cooperation are "soft factors" such as trust and expertise.
Keywords: innovation cooperation, innovation ecosystem, Triple Helix, case study
Introduction
Knowledge and the complex phenomenon of innovation, which is closely linked to knowledge, play an increasingly significant role in sustainable economic development. Although researchers in the field trace the concept of innovation back to Schumpeter (1934), the term is highly multifaceted, and its semantic scope is continuously expanding. The international consensus-based interpretation of innovation is established by the Oslo Manual (2018, 20), which defines innovation as "a new or improved product or process (goods or services) that differs significantly from the unit's previous products or processes and that has been made available to users or brought into use by the unit". This publication was produced with the professional support of the Doctoral Student Scholarship Programme of the Cooperative Doctoral Programme of the Ministry of Innovation and Technology, funded by the National Research, Development and Innovation Fund.
It is important, however, to note that innovation is a process that is both costly and uncertain. This is because the development of a new product or service can take years, whereas market success cannot be predicted with certainty (Rogers 1982; Bélyácz 2019). In order for economic actors engaged in innovation activities to reduce the aforementioned costs and risks to some extent, the establishment of formal and informal collaborations for innovation purposes among economic actors has become increasingly widespread since the 1980s (Dyer–Nobeoka 2000; Jarjabka–Weiner 2012).
Recently, the importance of the aforementioned innovation collaborations has visibly increased further; for instance, the Covid-19 pandemic highlighted the issue of resilience and, consequently, the importance of trust-based cooperation between market actors. The latest report from the World Economic Forum (WEF 2020) also identified the promotion of functioning innovation ecosystems as one of the main drivers of post-pandemic economic recovery. Furthermore, a survey conducted by IBM (2022) among executives revealed that while fifteen years ago companies primarily relied on internal R&D results, today 80 per cent of corporate leaders implement their innovation activities through some form of collaboration.
Given that the topic of innovation ecosystems is becoming increasingly popular in both scientific and governmental and corporate decision-making circles, yet so far few academically rigorous case studies have been produced in Hungary, a comprehensive examination of Hungarian innovation ecosystems is timely from both theoretical and practical perspectives.
This research builds upon the results of a previous literature review (Horváth 2021; 2022), during which I identified the five most frequently occurring factors of ecosystem management through a bibliometric study conducted within the Scopus database; these factors were linked by the respective authors to the effective leadership and organisation of ecosystems. Building on this, this case study presents the practical operation of innovation ecosystem management by analysing the agricultural innovation ecosystem of the Hungarian corporation Tungsram. The aim of the research is to analyse the strengths and weaknesses of the ecosystem, as well as the practical manifestation of the factors identified during the bibliometric study, based on semi-structured interviews conducted with the participants of the ecosystem under investigation. The ecosystem examined involves foreign and Hungarian higher education institutions, small enterprises, and government actors, providing a clear example of innovation ecosystems operating according to the Triple Helix model attributed to Etzkowitz and Leydesdorff (1996).
The structure of the article is as follows: first, I define the interpretative frameworks of the concept of the innovation ecosystem based on a detailed literature review, after which I briefly present the research methodology and the ecosystem under investigation.
Within the framework of the results, I present the strengths and weaknesses of the Tungsram ecosystem, as well as the practical challenges related to ecosystem management. The study concludes by drawing conclusions and designating directions for further research.
Literature Review
Providing a scientifically rigorous definition of the concept of the innovation ecosystem is crucial because, as Gobble (2014) notes, the term 'ecosystem' is used nowadays as a kind of buzzword; consequently, numerous scientific works, analyses, and strategies employ the concept without readers being precisely aware of its meaning. Therefore, as the theoretical foundation of this research, the following section reviews the scientific background of the concept of the innovation ecosystem and, within it, the Triple Helix model.
Conceptual Frameworks of Innovation Ecosystems and the Triple Helix Model
The concept of the ecosystem as an organisational system first appeared in the field of natural sciences, specifically in ecological research. In the interpretation of Willis (1997, p. 268), a biological ecosystem is a "complex set of relationships between actors, which are interconnected on a given spatial or structural basis, and their environment, the primary goal of which is to maintain a state of sustainable equilibrium".
The term first appeared in the field of economics in Frosch and Gallopoulos's (1989) article *Strategies for Manufacturing*, in which they analysed the negative impact of industrial production processes on the environment. Interestingly, the authors originally titled the study *Manufacturing – The Industrial Ecosystem View*, but the journal (at that time) rejected such a use of the term 'ecosystem'.
A few years later, Moore (1993) successfully introduced the concept to the fields of business and management studies by creating the term 'business ecosystem'. In the interpretation of Moore (1993; 1996), a business ecosystem is an economic/business-oriented community in which its participants—the interacting organisations and individuals—evolve together.
(co-evolve) in order to successfully adapt to the external and internal changes experienced in their environment, and to satisfy the needs of their consumers and the market. Not long after, Nalebuff–Brandenburger (1996) formulated the concept of co-opetition, the essence of which is that, instead of self-interested, competitive behaviour, it is in the long-term interest of all economic actors to expand and shape market opportunities, which, however, necessitates cooperation between companies. As an example, Philips developed HDTV as early as the 1980s, yet the cameras and broadcasting technology required for transmission only reached the market twenty years later. Ecosystem thinking therefore anticipates that it is not enough to focus solely on our own innovation activities; we must also bear in mind who else needs to innovate alongside us, and who must inevitably adopt our innovations in order for us to be successful in the market (Adner 2012).
The widespread use of the term business ecosystem was significantly influenced by Gawer–Cusumano’s (2002) business platform theory, which interpreted the concept of an ecosystem specifically in relation to technological giants (Intel, Cisco, Microsoft), as well as by Chesbrough’s (2003) open innovation model.
The first appearance of the innovation ecosystem as a standalone concept can be attributed to Adner. In Adner’s (2006) study, a clear distinction had not yet been made between business and innovation ecosystems; however, it was emphasised that the members of innovation ecosystems are always driven by an intention to innovate in their cooperation. Subsequently, numerous recognised authors began to interpret business and innovation ecosystems as distinct concepts, such as Adner–Kapoor (2010), Zahra–Nambisan (2010), Autio–Thomas (2014), Adner (2017), Yaghmaie–Vanhaverbeke (2020), and Visscher et al. (2021). The greatest difference between the two types of ecosystems is that while the business ecosystem primarily strives for value capture derived from the added value provided by cooperation, the innovation ecosystem focuses on value creation (Valkokari 2015). A comparison of the two concepts is presented in Table 1.
Overall, under Granstrand–Holgersson’s (2020, 6) interpretation, the concept of an innovation ecosystem is understood as: "the sum of actors, activities, resources, institutions, and the consciously shaped relationships between them, which are decisive for the innovation performance and value-creation capability of an economic actor or a set of actors".
The fundamental characteristic of innovation ecosystems is, therefore, that instead of focusing on institutional frameworks or resources, they place organically forming, in many cases dynamically changing, and typically cross-industry, value-creating relationships at the centre of the innovation process, rather than institutionalised cooperation. Table 1. Conceptual comparison of business and innovation ecosystems. Criteria. Literature reference.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
One of the most widespread models of innovation ecosystems is the Triple Helix model, attributable to Etzkowitz and Leydesdorff (1996). The essence of the model lies in the fact that, in a knowledge-based economy and society, the potential for innovation and economic development resides, on the one hand, in the changing role of higher education institutions, and on the other, in the dynamic system of relationships between higher education and economic actors, as well as the government, which induces the emergence of new institutional and social forms, thereby facilitating the process of creating, transferring, and applying knowledge and innovation (Vas 2012).
Since the knowledge possessed and utilised by individual economic actors constitutes only a small fraction of the resources required for the economic development and innovation activities of a given organisation, [it is necessary to strengthen the connections between actors] among state institutions aiming to promote operation and development (Cai 2014).
The model is illustrated in Figure 1.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The partner circle of ecosystems is typically heterogeneous, and participants may change dynamically. Within the Lanzolla–Markides (2022); Gu–Hu–Zang–Hou (2021); Talmar–Walrave–Podoynitsyna–Holmström–Romme (2020); Ruuska–Teigland (2009); Beelen–Jansen–Overbeek (2022); ecosystem, there may also be more closely or loosely connected organisations; the primary question is how they contribute to achieving the ecosystem's objective. (Thus, even a more loosely connected participant can be of key importance.) Consequently, partners must be selected based on the resources and knowledge capacity at their disposal. It is not the participants' past performance that is essential, but rather their future potential exploitable from the perspective of the ecosystem.
Especially in the case of SMEs, partner selection based on reputation is more prominent (“I do not cooperate with organisations that are 'invisible' to me.”).
Oh–Philips–Park–Lee (2016)
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The operational structure of ecosystems can take numerous forms, depending primarily on the number of participants, their area of operation, and the objectives of the ecosystem. The primary principle for designing the organisational system is functionality and flexibility, while its fundamental goal is the implementation of organised cooperation based on reciprocity. There is no explicit classification of the operational structures of ecosystems; however, Jacobides, Cennamo, and Gawer (2018) distinguish between open and closed ecosystem systems. An open ecosystem is characterised by trust-based relationships, long-term commitment, and frequent changes in the circle of participants. In contrast, a closed ecosystem is based on contractual relations, where trust is less established.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The leader of an ecosystem may be an individual or an organisation (Collien, 2021). If the ecosystem is organised around a key firm, the foreign literature refers to the managing company as a “keystone firm” or “gatekeeper” (Mors–Rogan–Lynch, 2018; Zhao–Anand, 2013; Champeonis–Etzkowitz, 2018; Ferdinand–Meyer, 2017; Johnson, 2008; Lundberg, 2013; Velu, 2015; Dedehayir–Mäkinen, 2015). If the ecosystem is multipolar—that is, consisting of roughly equal organisations interacting with one another—it is common to have a consensus-elected (potentially external) leader, which the literature refers to as a “boundary spanner”, “knowledge broker”, or, in the case of an organisation, a “hybrid autonomous organisation”.
Characteristics of the leader: independence, impartiality, high-level expertise, authentic representation of interests, consensus-seeking, and relationship-building behaviour (Ort, 2018; Jiang–Hu–Wang, 2019; Stonig–Müller, 2019; Stevens, 2019; Klimas–Czakon, 2022; Furr–Shipilov, 2018; Suominen–Seppänen–Dedehayir, 2018). The leader should primarily strive to build consensus rather than compromise. The reason for this is that if the mediator is too much of a “diplomat”—that is, attempting to accommodate individual interests at the expense of the common goal—they will undermine cooperation in the long term.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The aggregate of the individual market adaptability of ecosystem participants does not equal the adaptability of the ecosystem as an organisational system. This is because, according to Khurana–Dutta (2021); Heaton–Siegel–Teece (2019); Rabelo–Bernus (2015); Morais–Martins–Ferreira dos Santos (2022); Fukuda (2020); Boyer–Ozor–Rondé (2021); Vigren–Kadefors–Eriksson (2022); Sahasranamam–Soundararajan (2022), an ecosystem is composed of market-based, self-interested organisations; if the structure and objectives of the cooperation do not adapt appropriately to external and resistant internal changes, the individual participants may realise diminishing benefits from the ecosystem, leading to its dissolution. We can therefore speak of the ecosystem's organisational resilience if the cooperation of the participants creates value in a way that participants could not, or could only achieve more expensively or time-consumingly, achieve on their own.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The prerequisite for the establishment of an ecosystem is a community of interest, whereas the basis of its operation is trust.
In ecosystemic collaborations, the presence of trust signifies two things simultaneously. On the one hand, it denotes goodwill, i.e., the assumption that other partners also have an interest in the most efficient operation and development of the ecosystem. On the other hand, we can speak of competence-based trust, which represents confidence in the expertise and proficiency of the other ecosystem participants. In summary, the actors within an ecosystem must simultaneously trust that their partners will fulfil their assigned tasks and that they truly possess the resources required to perform them. However, excessive trust leads to a flattening of innovation activity; thus, maintaining healthy competition among participants is of key importance. An excessive weight placed on informal relationships carries the inherent risk of "not speaking the same language" and, in extreme cases, the risk of abuse.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
The literature review reveals that ecosystem management is an emerging field of research; while there is no unified approach to the concept, a common knowledge base can already be identified from a practical perspective, as case studies addressing this issue typically regard similar factors as the foundation of effective and successful ecosystem organisation. In the present study, I analyse the functioning of a Hungarian innovation ecosystem using qualitative methods in the form of a case study. During the research, I sought to answer two questions: 1. What strengths and weaknesses did the ecosystem participants identify regarding the application of the Triple Helix innovation model during the functioning of the ecosystem? (applied method: expert interviews) 2. What correlations can be identified within the examined cooperation between the factors of ecosystem management identified by Horváth (2021)? (applied method: Likert-scale questionnaire, correlation analysis) Methodology The present research can be considered exploratory and explanatory research, given that there is little scientifically rigorous analysis available regarding the practice of innovation cooperation in Hungary. Although an inherent limitation of the case study method (particularly studies based on a single case) is that general conclusions regarding the topic cannot be drawn based on the results obtained, it remains a frequently applied method in the field of management sciences, as it is highly effective for gaining a practical, comprehensive, and in-depth understanding of scientific problems (Yin 2018; Saunders et al. 2019).
I examined the two research questions using qualitative methods, document analysis, and the conduct of 26 semi-structured expert interviews. In selecting the interviewees, one primary criterion was that the senior management of every organisation involved in the cooperation should express their opinion on the strategic importance of participating in the collaboration; secondly, my aim was to interview every colleague who actually works within the cooperation at an operational level. The resulting two-tier interviews provided a comprehensive picture of both the long-term and the day-to-day challenges of the cooperation.
I employed a separate set of questions to examine the lead company, the partner companies, the university partners, and the state participants; this was necessary because each interviewee is a member of the cooperation from a different perspective. Furthermore, during the interviews, I placed great emphasis on mapping the formal and informal relationships between the individual partners, as well as daily work organisation experiences. In order to ensure the comparability and synthesisation of the responses, the core subject areas remained consistent throughout the interviews.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
In the following, I first present the operation of the examined ecosystem and the circle of partners, and subsequently present the research findings in connection with the aforementioned research questions. The use of quotations was conducted with the consent of the respondents in all instances.
Presentation of the examined ecosystem
Following its independence from GE in 2018, Tungsram has faced numerous market, business, technological, and organisational challenges, which were further exacerbated by the unfavourable macroeconomic environment and the disruption of supply chains caused by the Covid–19 pandemic (Bauer 2019). Consequently, the company's objective is to concentrate its remaining resources on innovative markets that, by utilising both Tungsram's lighting technology manufacturing capacities and sales expertise, create long-term stable profit-making and growth opportunities for the company. Such areas include smart city management systems, or the indoor farming industrial segment examined in this study.
The indoor farming industrial segment first came to the company's attention due to LED light sources. Indoor farming places the food production process primarily on technological foundations. The aim of indoor farming is to create optimal conditions for high-yield, resource-efficient crop production, while eliminating seasonal yield fluctuations caused by weather and other external factors. Consequently, one requirement of indoor or closed-system farming is the modern indoor LED lighting of plants, which can essentially replace natural sunlight, either partially or entirely, during crop cultivation (Despommier 2010).
As a light source manufacturer possessing significant manufacturing capacities and sales experience, Tungsram identified the indoor farming industrial segment as a new market. However, since several larger competitors (Philips Signify, Hortilux, etc.) were already present in the light source manufacturing market related to indoor farming at the time of Tungsram's entry, the company consistently strove for differentiation and the servicing of specialised customer requirements.
During the market introduction of Tungsram's indoor agricultural light source product family, the company experienced that for potentially capital-rich large buyers—such as foreign greenhouse-owning companies—the opportunity to test lamps and perform various measurements, as well as to customise light sources prior to purchase, is of paramount importance; however, most industrial players lack the infrastructure for this. In order to more targetedly serve these niche market needs, Tungsram set the goal of establishing its own indoor farming unit to serve as a kind of testing environment. Within this framework—recognising that Tungsram possesses no relevant market experience related to either the agricultural sector or the food industry—the company sought partners, primarily in Hungary, who already possess the technological and food industry knowledge related to agricultural innovations.
In the ecosystemic collaboration, four additional partners participate alongside Tungsram as the leading company: a Hungarian small business specialising in biotechnology, a market-leading Hungarian lettuce processing and sales company, a Hungarian agricultural university, a Dutch agricultural university, and a Hungarian government body responsible for managing innovation tenders. The division of labour among the participants in the ecosystem has been clearly defined since the start of the collaboration, as the individual actors are not competitors in the market but possess complementary and highly combinable resources; thus, the participants have not experienced any conflict of interest during the operation of the ecosystem to date.
Within the ecosystem, the state body participates primarily in an indirect manner by providing financial (grant) support, whereas the biotechnology company focuses mainly on the development of the indoor farm, and the salad processing company's objective is the commercialisation and market introduction of the vegetables and fruits producible on the farm. Universities also participate in the R&D processes, albeit from a different perspective: while the Dutch university is a member of the ecosystem primarily to implement its existing research findings, the Hungarian higher education institution conducts more basic and applied research on the farm, particularly given that similar infrastructure is unavailable elsewhere in Hungary. The motivations and objectives of the individual participants are summarised in Table 4. As Figure 3 also demonstrates, the ecosystem participants are known to one another within the agri-food industry, and connections exist between actors beyond the Tungsram ecosystem. Based on the interviews, we attributed the stability and relatively narrow scope of the partner circle to two main reasons: (1) mutual interdependence; and (2) good personal relationships. The "sense of mutual interdependence" perceived by the participants stemmed primarily from the fact that indoor farming was not widespread in Hungary (nor explicitly in Europe) from either a technological or a food industry perspective. Consequently, Tungsram's opportunities were largely determined by the narrow circle of potential corporate and university partners operating in this market segment. As one colleague working at Tungsram put it: "it was actually clear from the beginning whom we had to cooperate with to make the project happen, since at that time there was approximately only one company that possessed the necessary know-how"; "now I think we could find others as well, but it is better to work with those we know". This was also confirmed by the corporate and university partners: "there is no other Hungarian company that could have undertaken such an investment, so it was not a question of whether we were involved; we do not have that much capital for innovation"; "Tungsram had infrastructure that we would not be able to access in any other way, so from our perspective, this cooperation currently has no alternative in Hungary". Furthermore, in addition to mutual interdependence, the partner circle is influenced by the existence of good personal relationships between organisations and individuals. As the corporate partners expressed during the interviews: "I don't even remember exactly what it was, but I know that I asked Tungsram whether we should also contact them (another company), because this might be interesting to them as well"; "we have known each other for quite a long time, as the food industry is a rather small segment in Hungary; I was glad that we are working together with them, because they understand the field". Table 4. Identification of the motivations and objectives of the partners participating in the ecosystem Partner Type of Cooperation initial area
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
According to the accounts of the ecosystem participants, there is no explicit operational structure; however, the partners regard the head of Tungram's agricultural innovation business unit as the ecosystem manager. In the following chapter, I will elaborate in detail on the practical experiences of the cooperation and the results regarding the correlations between the individual ecosystem management factors.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Based on the cooperation interviews, the primary advantage identified is the opportunity to combine resources, which is generally characteristic of ecosystems (Bittencourt et al. 2021; Maritan–Peteraf 2011). Since indoor farming requires both technical and food industry expertise, the ecosystem form of cooperation facilitates the linking of the resources of individual industry actors, through which the participants are able to create greater value than they could independently. In this regard, according to the assessment of the corporate partners, the balanced functioning of the ecosystem is significantly contributed to by the fact that competitors do not participate in the cooperation, the corporate participants do not operate within the same industry, and their objectives are not mutually conflicting.
The actors also identified the existence of trust-based relationships between participants as a strength and one of the main characteristics of the ecosystem. Based on the conducted interviews, the functioning of the Tungram ecosystem is largely determined by the fact that the partners know each other—in many cases through previous relationships. One respondent characterised the importance of trust in the cooperation as follows: "In a project as complex and risky as this indoor farm, if there is no good relationship, cooperation becomes impossible, as the matter is inherently resource-intensive and the outcome is not certain: who would take a risk with a partner they do not even trust?" Based on the interviews, Tungram and the participating partners identified that the cooperation did not facilitate the procurement of external funding required to continue the project, primarily the involvement of venture capital; therefore, the cooperation is increasingly characterised by a lack of resources. The state partner provided, in essence, the innovation grant for the construction of the farm, which has already been exhausted by the market entry and commercialisation stage.
All of this reinforces the so-called European paradox, according to which EU member states generally struggle to bring inventions and basic research results to market, partly due to poor support structures (basic research orientation) (Héder 2017; Tóthné-Kiss 2017; Argyropoulou et al. 2019). In this connection, Tungsram's partners highlighted that, in addition to defining the objective of the ecosystem, the company (and its partners) outlined actual strategic directions and potential business models only late in the process. Consequently, the indoor farm operated by Tungsram, along with the LED light source development, food product development, and other research activities carried out there, fragmented the ecosystem's resources. As one partner characterised the problem: "daily workflows are always smooth, but making truly important decisions is significantly slower. This could be helped if it were clear to everyone which direction we are heading in." A further weakness of the cooperation is that the flexible operation of the ecosystem is difficult for university bureaucracy to manage. Based on their previous experiences, corporate partners generally hold no positive views regarding the operation of Hungarian higher education institutions, as one corporate partner put it: "we have tried to cooperate with universities before, but the decision-making structure is so widespread that by the time the question reaches the relevant person, the subject of the inquiry is already outdated. Universities should react much faster to market demands." Alongside bureaucracy, several interviewees also highlighted that although it would be cheaper to perform certain parts of the R&D processes in cooperation with Hungarian universities, market players—lacking confidence in the competencies of Hungarian higher education institutions—often prefer to entrust development to a more expensive market actor. The university partners also sense these weak connections (particularly the Hungarian partner); however, in their view, besides university and corporate bureaucracy, the primary reason for this is that the university party is unable to position itself appropriately within the cooperation, and the added value of higher education institutions within the ecosystem is unclear. At the same time, the parties made good use of university-corporate relations in recruiting specialists for the indoor farm, as almost all employees at the farm completed their studies at the Hungarian university partner—in this respect, the role of the university as a knowledge centre and for knowledge transfer is prominently evident in the cooperation (especially in a specialised industrial segment such as indoor farming). Given that the foreign university partner only participates in a few key developments, while there is a demand on the part of the Hungarian higher education institution to tighten these connections, it remains an interesting question whether the role of the Hungarian university partner could be enhanced within the ecosystem, or whether it will remain a background player in the future.
Correlations between certain factors of ecosystem management
During the semi-structured interviews, I presented the participants with the ecosystem management factors, which had been introduced in detail in the first part of the study, and asked the respondents to rank the five factors according to their importance using a Likert scale. In the course of the study, I treated the Likert scale responses as ordinal variables; however, since the "PART-
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Conclusions
In the present study, I first presented the concept of innovation ecosystems, and subsequently, in the second half of the study, the results of an empirical investigation into an agri-innovation ecosystem led by the Hungarian corporation Tungsram.
The research sought to answer two research questions: 1. what strengths and weaknesses did the participants identify in the practical application of the Triple Helix innovation ecosystem model; and 2. based on the participants' experiences, what correlations can be identified between the five previously presented factors related to ecosystem management within the investigated ecosystem? The first question was examined through expert interviews and informal discussions, while the second was investigated using correlation analysis based on the respondents' Likert-scale evaluations.
From the results, it can be concluded that the participants primarily view the key to the successful operation of the ecosystem as residing in "soft" or otherwise difficult-to-measure factors, such as trust-based relationships between partners and the appropriate interconnection and combination of the individual participants' resources.
In the selection of partners, the existence of personal good relations (based on recommendations) is decisive alongside competence. Participants assess the resource scarcity occurring during cooperation, as well as the lack of a clear strategy, as challenges or difficulties; as a consequence, participants currently perceive a fragmentation of the ecosystem's otherwise scarce resources.
During the interviews, we uncovered a perceptible competence-based mistrust between corporate partners and Hungarian higher education institutions, which can be attributed to two reasons. One is the frequently cited problem of bureaucracy and slow decision-making processes in relation to universities, while the other is the mistrust of companies regarding the expertise of universities. Consequently, I identified the weakest links within the Triple Helix model to be between the corporate and university participants. The university partners also perceive these weak links (particularly the Hungarian partner); however, in their view, alongside university and corporate bureaucracy, the primary reason for this is that the university party is unable to position itself appropriately within the cooperation, meaning that the added value of higher education institutions within the ecosystem is not clear.
The results of the correlation analysis show a negative relationship between the selection of the partner circle and the importance of establishing an operational structure. Based on the interviews, it can be concluded that the establishment of the organisational structure gained importance during the current stage of the ecosystem—the innovation commercialisation stage—because entering the market requires the development of a clear strategy and business model, for which participants feel a closer integration and more effective management of the cooperation is necessary. A further negative relationship can be discovered between the importance of the leader's persona and the adaptive and resilient capacities of the ecosystem. The responses suggest that the persona of the ecosystem leader is more important to those who are less integrated into the cooperation—such as higher education institutions—whereas the resilience of the ecosystem is considered important by those participating in the ecosystem with long-term, profit-oriented goals—notably the corporate actors. Suggestions for improving the operation of the ecosystem, specifically regarding partners, are summarised in Figure 4.
Since the qualitative case study method employed in the present study is not suitable for drawing generalisable conclusions, further research directions will include, on the one hand, a continued investigation of the Tungram ecosystem following the company's reorganisation processes; on the other hand, I plan to conduct case studies of other types of ecosystems in Hungary, which will allow for a more detailed understanding of the functioning of Hungarian ecosystems. I trust that the practices uncovered will serve as valuable lessons not only for academic research but also for current and future ecosystem leaders and participants, as well as for policy makers.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.
Bibliography
References
- Aarikka-Stenroos, L.–Ritala, P. 2017. Network management in the era of ecosystems: Systematic review and management framework. Industrial Marketing Management 67(8), 23–36.
- Adner, R. 2006. Match Your Innovation Strategy to Your Innovation Ecosystem. Harvard Business Review 34(4), 98–107.
- Adner, R. 2012. Wide Lens – a New Strategy for Innovation. London: Portfolio Penguin.
- Adner, R. 2017. Ecosystem as Structure: An Actionable Construct for Strategy. Journal of Management 43(1), 39–58.
- Adner, R.–Kapoor, R. 2010. Value Creation in Innovation Ecosystems: How The Structure of Technological Interdependence affects Firm Performance in New Technology Generations. Strategic Management Journal 31(3), 306–333.
- Alam, M. A.–Rooney D.–Taylor, M. 2022. From ego-systems to open innovation ecosystems: A process model of inter-firm openness. Journal of Product Innovation Management 39(2), 177–201.
- Aramesh, H. 2021. Analyzing the Ecological Pillars of Innovation Ecosystem Based on Bibliometric Method. International Journal of Business and Developmental Studies 13(1), 146–161.
- Argyropoulou, M.–Soderquist, K. E.–Ioannou, G. 2019. Getting out of the European Paradox trap: Making European research agile and challenge driven. European Management Journal 37(1), 1–5.
- Autio, E.–Thomas, L. D. W. 2014. Innovation Ecosystems – Implications for Innovation Management. In: Dodgson, M.–Gann, D. M.–Philips, N. (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Innovation Management. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 204–228.
- Bacon, E.–Williams, M. D.–Davies, G. H. 2019. Recipes for success: Conditions for knowledge transfer across open innovation ecosystems. International Journal of Information Management 49(December), 377–387.
- Barbier, E. B.–Burgess, J. C. 2020. Sustainability and development after COVID-19. World Development 135(November), 1–4.
- Bauer, J. 2019. Vállvetve: Magyarország és Tungsram. In: Parragh, B. (ed.): Ösztönző állam – hatékonyabb vállalatok. Budapest: Akadémiai Kiadó, 307–319.
- Beelen, L.–Jansen, S.–Overbeek, S. 2022. Are you of value to me? A partner selection reference method for software ecosystem orchestrators. Science of Computer Programming 2014(Febrary), 1–8.
- Bélyácz, I. 2019. Corporate strategy and competitiveness in a knowledge-based economy. Közgazdász Fórum 22(141), 3–11.
- Benitez, G. B.–Ayala, N. F.–Frank, A. G. 2020. Industry 4.0 innovation ecosystems: an evolutionary perspective on value cocreation. International Journal of Production Economics 228(October), 1–13.
- Bittencourt, B. A.–Santos, D. A. G.–Mignoni, J, 2021. Resource orchestration in innovation ecosystems: a comparative study between innovation ecosystems at different stages of development. International Journal of Innovation 9(1), 108–130.
- Boyer, J.–Ozor, J.–Rondé, P. 2021. Local innovation ecosystem: structure and impact on adaptive capacity of firms. Industry and Innovation 28(4), 620–650.
- Cai, Y. 2014. Implementing the Triple Helix model in a non-Western context: an institutional logics perspective. Triple Helix Journal 1(1), 1–20.
- Cavallo, A.–Ghezzi, A.–Balocco, R. 2019. Entrepreneurial ecosystem research: present debates and future directions. International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal 15(4), 1291–1321.
- Champenois, C.–Etzkowitz, H. 2018. From boundary line to boundary space: The creation of hybrid organizations as a Triple Helix micro-foundation. Technovation 76-77(August-September), 28–39.
- Chesbrough, H. 2003. Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from Technology. Boston: Harvard Business School Publishing Corporation.
- Chesbrough, H. 2020. Open Innovation Results: Going beyond the hype & getting down to business. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Chesbrough, H.–Kim, S.–Agogino, A. 2014. Chez Panisse: Building an Open Innovation Ecosystem. California Management Review 56(4), 144–171.
- Clarysse, B.–Wright, M.–Bruneel, J.–Mahajan, A. 2014. Creating value in ecosystems: Crossing the chasm between knowledge and business ecosystems. Research Policy 43(7), 1164–1176.
- Cobben, D.–Roijakkers, N. 2019. The dynamics of trustand control in innovation ecosystems. International Journal of Innovation 7(1), 1–25.
- Collien, I. 2021. Concepts of power in boundary spanning research: A review and research agenda. International Journal of Management Reviews 23(4), 443–465.
- Davis, J. P. 2016. The Group Dynamics of Interorganizational Relationships. Administrative Science Quarterly 61(4), 621–661.
- Dedehayir, O.–Mäkinen, S. J.–Roland Ortt, J. 2018. Roles during innovation ecosystem genesis: A literature review. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 136(November), 18–29.
- Despommier, D. (2010). The Vertical Farm: Feeding the World in the 21st Century. London: Picador.
- Dyer, J. H.–Nobeoka, K. 2000. Creating and managing a high-performance knowledgesharing network: The Toyota case. Strategic Management Journal 21(3), 345–367.
- Etzkowitz, H.–Leydesdorff, L. 1996. Emergence of a Triple Helix of UniversityIndustry-Government Relations. Science and Public Policy 23(5), 279–286.
- Etzkowitz, H.–Leydesdorff, L. 2000. The dynamics of innovation: from National Systems and „Mode 2” to Triple Helix of university-industry-government relations. Research Policy 29(2), 109–123.
- Etzkowitz, H.–Zhou, C. 2018. The Triple Helix: Universtiy–Industry–Government Innovation and Entrepreneurship. New York: Routledge.
- Ferasso, M.–Takahashi, A. R. W.–Gimenez, F. A. P. 2018. Innovation Ecosystems: A Meta-Synthesis. International Journal of Innovation Science 10(4), 495–518.
- Ferdinand, J.-P.–Meyer, U. 2017. The social dynamics of heterogeneous innovation ecosystems. International Journal of Engineering Business Management 9(1), 1–16.
- Frosch, R.–Gallopoulos, N. 1989. Strategies for Manufacturing. Scientific American 189(3), 144–152.
- Fukuda, K. 2020. Science, technology and innovation ecosystem transformation toward society 5.0. International Journal of Production Economics 2020(February), 1–14.
- Furr, N.–Shipilov, A. 2018. Building the Right Ecosystem for Innovation. MIT Sloan Management Review. https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/building-the-right-ecosystem-for-innovation/, letöltve: 2022. 05. 10.
- Gawer, A.–Cusumano, M. A. 2002. Platform Leadership: How Intel, Microsoft and Cisco Drive Industry Innovation. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
- Giest, S. 2017. Trust Dynamics in Innovation Networks: The Chicago Life Science Cluster. Administration & Society 51(2), 1–19.
- Gobble, M. M. 2014. Charting the Innovation Ecosystem. Research Technology Management 57(4), 55–59.
- Gomes, L. A de V–Facin, A. L. F.–Salerno, M. S. 2021. Managing uncertainty propagation in innovation ecosystems. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 171(October), 1–13.
- Gomes, V. de L. A.–Facin, A. L. F.–Salerno, M. S.–Ikenami, R. K. 2018. Unpacking The Innovation Ecosystem Construct: Evolution, Gaps and Trends. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 136(11), 30–48.
- Granstrand, O.–Holgersson, M. 2020. Innovation Ecosystems: A Conceptual Review and a New Definition. Technovation 90–91(February-March), 1–12.
- Gu, Y.–Hu L.–Zang, H.–Hou, Z. 2021. Innovation Ecosystem Research: Emerging Trends and Future Research. Sustainability 13(20), 1–21.
- Hannah, D. P.–Eisenhardt, K. M. 2017. How firms navigate cooperation and competition in nascent ecosystems. Strategic Management Journal 39(12), 3163–3192.
- Heaton, S.–Siegel, D. S.–Teece, D. J. 2019. Universities and innovation ecosystems: a dynamic capabilities perspective. Industrial and Corporate Change 28(4), 921–939.
- Héder, M. 2017. From NASA to EU: the evolution of the TRL scale in Public Sector Innovation. The Innovation Journal: The Public Sector Innovation Journal 22(2), 1–24.
- Hoffmann, W.–Lavie, D.–Reuer, J. J.–Shipilov, A. 2018. The interplay of competition and cooperation. Strategic Management Journal 39(12), 3033–3052.
- Horváth, K. 2021. Az innovációs ökoszisztéma menedzsment strukturális kihívásai – a szakirodalom tükrében. Marketing&Menedzsment 55(3), 71–82.
- Horváth, K. 2022. Az innovációs ökoszisztéma menedzsment strukturális kihívásai – szakirodalmi áttekintés és empirikus eredmények. In: Kiss, R.–Urbanovics, A. (eds.) A Haza Szolgálatában Konferenciakötet 2021. Budapest: DOSZ, 8–19. hvg.hu 2022. Két vidéki városban kezdi a Tungsram az elbocsájtásokat. https://hvg. hu/kkv/20220428_tungsram_leepites_kisvarda_hajduboszormeny, letöltve: 2022. 05. 06. IBM, 2022. Open the Door to Open Innovation. https://www.ibm.com/downloads/ cas/WBXEQXEW, letöltve: 2022. 05. 10.
- Jacobides, G. M.–Cennamo, C.–Gawer, A. 2018. Towards a Theory of Ecosystems. Strategic Management Journal 39(8), 2255–2276.
- Jarjabka, Á.–Weiner, J. 2012. The importance and aspects of training in EU cluster development. Közgazdász Fórum 15(6), 29–47.
- Jiang, S.–Hu, Y.–Wang, Z. 2019. Core Firm Based View on the Mechanism of Constructing an Enterprise Innovation Ecosystem: A Case Study of Haier Group. Sustainability 11(11), 1–26.
- Johnson, W. H. A. 2008. Roles, resources and benefits of intermediate organizations supporting triple helix collaborative R&D: The case of Precarn. Technovation 28(8), 495– 505.
- Jones, S. L.–Leiponen, A.–Vasudeva, G. 2020. The evolution of cooperation in the face of conflict: Evidence from the innovation ecosystem for mobile telecom standards development. Strategic Management Journal 42(4), 710–740.
- Ketonen-Oksi, S.–Valkokari, K. 2019. Innovation Ecosystems as Structures for Value Co-Creation. Technology Innovation Management Review 9(2), 25–35.
- Khurana, I.–Dutta, D. K. 2021. From latent to emergent entrepreneurship in innovation ecosystems: The role of entrepreneurial learning. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 167(June), 1–12.
- Klimas, P.–Czakon, W. 2022. Gaming innovation ecosystem: actors, roles and coinnovation processes. Review of Managerial Science 16(3), 645–656.
- Könnölä, T.–Eloranta, V.–Turunen, T.–Salo, A. 2021. Transformative governance of innovation ecosystems. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 173(December), 1–14.
- Lanzolla, G.–Markides, C. C. 2022. How to Choose the Right Ecosystem Partners for Your Business. https://hbr.org/2022/03/how-to-choose-the-right-ecosystem-partnersfor-your-business, letöltve: 2022. 05. 30.
- Letaifa, S. M. 2014. The Uneasy Transition from Supply Chains to Ecosystems: The Value-creation/Value-capture Dilemma. Management Decision 52(2), 278–295.
- Lundberg, H. 2013. Triple Helix in practice: the key role of boundary spanners. European Journal of Innovation Management 16(2), 211–226.
- Luo, J. 2017. Architecture and evolvability of innovation ecosystems. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 136(November), 132–144.
- Mantovani, A.–Ruiz-Aliseda, F. 2016. Equilibrium Innovation Ecosystems: The Dark Side of Collaborating with Complementors. Management Science 62(2), 534–549.
- Maritan, C. A.–Peteraf, M. A. 2011. Building a Bridge Between Resource Acquisition and Resource Accumulation. Journal of Management 37(5), 1374–1389.
- Moore, J. F. 1993. Predators and Prey: A New Ecology of Competition. Harvard Business Review 71(3), 75–86.
- Moore, J. F. 1996. The Death of Competition: Leadership and Strategy in The Age of Business Ecosystems. New York: HarperBusiness.
- Morais, G. M.–Martins, H. C.–Ferreira dos Santos, V. 2022. Resilience in the Context of Pandemics and Disasters: A Framework for Public Governance, Ecosystem Innovation, Co-creation, and Co-production. International Journal of Business Administration 13(1), 15–29.
- Mors, M. L.–Rogan, M.–Lynch, S. E. 2018. Boundary spanning and knowledge exploration in a professional services firm. Journal of Professions and Organization 5(3), 184–205.
- Nalebuff, B. J.–Brandenburger, A. M. 1996. Co-opetition. New York: HarperCollinsBusiness.
- Nambisan, S.–Sawhney, M. 2011. Orchestration processes in network-centric innovation: Evidence from the field. The Academy of Management Perspectives 25(3), 40–57.
- OECD 2018. Oslo Manual 2018: Guidelines for Collecting, Reporting and Using Data on Innovation, The Measurement of Scientific, Technological and Innovation Activities. https://www.oecd.org/science/oslo-manual-2018-9789264304604-en.htm, letöltve: 2022. 04. 06.
- Oh, D. S.–Philips, F.–Park, S.–Lee, E. 2016. Innovation Ecosystems: A Cricital Examination. Technovation 54(August), 1–6.
- Papaioannou, T.–Wield, D.–Chataway, J. 2009. Knowledge Ecologies and Ecosystems? An Empirically Grounded Reflection on Recent Developments in Innovation Systems Theory. Environment and Planning, Government and Policy 27(2), 319–339.
- Pellikka, J.–Ali-Vehmas, T. 2016. Managing Innovation Ecosystems to Create and Capture Value in ICT Industries. Technology Innovation Management Review 6(10), 17–24.
- Philips, A. 2022. Trump saved this old-fashioned lightbulb. Biden’s now phasing it out. https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-solutions/2022/04/26/biden-incandescent-lightbulb-ban-trump/, letöltve: 2022. 05. 06.
- Rabelo, R. J.–Bernus, P. 2015. A Holistic Model of Building Innovation Ecosystems. IFAC-PapersOnLine 48(3), 2250–2257.
- Rogers, E. M. 1962. Diffusion of Innovations. New York: The Free Press.
- Russell, M. G.–Huhtamäki, J.–Still, K.–Rubens, N.–Basole, R. C. 2015. Relational capital for shared vision in innovation ecosystems. Triple Helix 2(8), 1–36.
- Ruuska, I.–Teigland, R. 2009. Ensuring project success through collective competence and creative conflict in public-private partnerships – A case study of Bygga Villa, a Swedish triple helix e-government initiative. International Journal of Project Management 27(4), 323–334.
- Sahasranamam, S.–Soundararajan V. 2021. Innovation Ecosystems: What Makes them Responsive during Emergencies? British Journal Management 33(1), 369–389.
- Sant’Ana, T. D.–Bermejo, P. H.–Moreira, M. F.–Souza, W. V. B. 2019. The structure of an innovation ecosystem: foundations for future research. Management Decisions 58(12), 2725–2742.
- Sára, Z.–Csedő, Z.–Fejes, J.–Tóth, T.–Pörzse, G. 2014. Innovációmenedzsment és innovációs stratégiák. Vezetéstudomány 45(10), 42–48.
- Saunders, M. N.–Lewis, P.–Thornhill, A. 2019. Research Methods for Business Students. London: Pearson.
- Scaringella, L.–Radziwon, A. 2018. Innovative Entrepreneurial Business Ecosystems: Old wine in new bottles? Technological Forecasting and Social Change 136(11), 59–87.
- Schroth, F.–Häußermann, J. J. 2018. Collaboration Strategies in Innovation Ecosystems: An Empirical Study of the German Microelectronics and Photonics Industries. Technology Innovation Management Review 8(11), 4–12.
- Schumpeter, J. A. 1934. The Theory of Economic Development: An Inquiry into
- Profits, Capital, Credit, Interest, and the Business Cycle. New Jersey: Transaction Books, New Brunswick.
- Shipilov, A.–Gawer, A. 2020. Integrating Research on Interorganizational Networks and Ecosystems. Academy of Management Annals 14(1), 1–70.
- Smith, K. R. 2006. Building an Innovation Ecosystem: Process, Culture and Competencies. Industry and Higher Education 20(4), 219–224.
- Steinbruch, F. K.–da Silva Nascimento, L.–de Menezes, D. C. 2022. The role of trust in innovation ecosystems. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing 37(1), 195–208.
- Stonig, J.–Müller-Stewens 2019. Navigating the Challenges of Ecosystem Emergence: A Multi-Level Review of Leader and Complementor Strategies. Die Unternehmung 73(4), 288–307.
- Suominen, A.–Seppänen, M.–Dedehayir, O. 2018. A bibliometric review on innovation systems and ecosystems: a research agenda. European Journal of Innovation Management 22(2), 335–360.
- Szerb, L. 2017. A vállalkozói ökoszisztéma Magyarországon a 2010-es években – helyzetértékelés és szakpolitikai javaslatok. Vezetéstudomány 48(6–7), 2–14.
- Talmar, M.–Walrave, B.–Podoynitsyna, K. S.–Holmström, J.–Romme, A. G. L. 2018. Mapping, analyzing and designing innovation ecosystems: The Ecosystem Pie Model. Long Range Planning 53(4), 1–9.
- Valkokari, K. 2015. Business, Innovation, and Knowledge Ecosystems: How They Differ and How to Survive and Thrive within Them. Technology Innovation Management Review 5(8), 17–24.
- Vas, Zs. 2012. Tudásalapú gazdaság és társadalom kiteljesedése: A Triple Helix továbbgondolása – a Quadruple és Quintuple Helix. In: Rechnitzer, J.–Rácz, Sz. (szerk.).
- Dialógus a regionális tudományról. Győr: Széchenyi István Egyetem Regionális- és Gazdaságtudományi Doktori Iskola; Magyar Regionális Tudományi Társaság, 198–206.
- Velu, C. 2015. Knowledge management capabilities of lead firms in innovation ecosystems. AMS Review 5(3–4), 12–141.
- Vigren, O.–Kadefors, A.–Eriksson, K. 2022. Digitalization, innovation capabilities and absorptive capacity in the Swedish real estate ecosystem. Facilities 40(15/16), 89–106.
- Visscher, K.–Hahnh, K.–Konrad, K. 2021. Innovation ecosystem strategies of industrial firms: A multilayered approach to alignment and strategic positioning. Creativity and Innovation Management 31(3), 1–13.
- Willis, A. J. 1997. The Ecosystem: An Evolving Conecpt Viewed Historically. Functional Ecology 11(2), 268–271.
- WEF 2020. Global Competitiveness Report Special Edition 2020: How Countries are Performing on the Road to Recovery. https://www.weforum.org/reports/the-globalcompetitiveness-report-2020/in-full, letöltve: 2022. 05. 10.
- Yahmaie, P.–Vanhaverbeke, W. 2020. Identifying and describing constituents of innovation ecosystems. EuroMed Journal of Business 15(3), 283–314.
- Yin, R. K. 2018. Case Study Research and Applications: Design and Methods. London: Sage.
- Zahra, S. A.–Nambisan, S. 2012. Entrepreneurship and Strategic Thinking in Business Ecosystems. Business Horizons 55(3), 219–229.
- Zhao, Z. J.–Anand, J. 2013. Beyond Boundary Spanners: The ‘Collective Bridge’ as an Efficient Interunit Structure for Transferring Collective Knowledge. Strategic Management Journal 34(1), 1513–1530.
A szöveget automatikusan nyertük ki a PDF-ből; a táblázatok, ábrák és a pontos tördelés a lapszám PDF-változatában láthatók.