← Összes podcast
2021/1. lapszám · Munkaerőpiac, oktatás, HR

The labour market integration of Hungarian youth in Transylvania: A snapshot of the factors determining youth labour market prospects, satisfaction, and propensity to emigrate

Csepeti Ádám, Bavlsík Richárd, Nagy Ákos

Megjelent: 2021 · Közgazdász Fórum, 2021/1. lapszám · Oldalak: 15–51

„Maradni vagy menni? Mit várnak a munkától az erdélyi magyar fiatalok?”

Meghallgatom a podcastot

Bővebb beszélgetés · 9 perc
HU EN A podcast nyelve: magyar · EN: az angol változat még nem készült el
0:00-8:41

Megjelent: 2021 · Közgazdász Fórum, 2021/1. lapszám · Oldalak: 15–51

A teljes cikk HU EN

OJS ↗ A teljes lapszám (PDF) ↗

This English text is a machine translation of the original Hungarian article, made with a local AI model. The original is authoritative: read the original (Hungarian)

Közgazdász Fórum · Issue 1/2021 · 15–51

The labour market integration of Hungarian youth in Transylvania: A snapshot of the factors determining youth labour market prospects, satisfaction, and propensity to emigrate

Abstract. In our study4, we present the most significant findings of an empirical research conducted in 2020, which examines the labour market situation of Hungarian youth in Transylvania within the Romanian labour market. During the exploratory in-depth interviews and the large-scale questionnaire survey, we placed particular emphasis on assessing the labour market prospects, propensity to emigrate, trust in social actors, and satisfaction with the labour market situation of Hungarian youth in Transylvania, as well as examining the importance and level of development of the skills and competencies required for labour market success. Alongside descriptive statistics presenting the attitudes, opinions, and preferences of young people regarding the labour market, we prioritised using multivariate statistical methods to identify similarities and differences between respondent groups with varying sociodemographic characteristics, as well as the impact of factors that weakly or strongly determine labour market prospects, satisfaction, and the propensity to emigrate. Our results highlight that although they assess their Romanian labour market prospects unfavourably, contrary to common belief, Hungarian youth in Transylvania are less inclined to emigrate abroad permanently. At the same time, according to the youth, the domestic school system does not support the acquisition of the skills and competencies necessary for successful Romanian labour market prospects to an adequate extent.

Keywords: labour market prospects, labour market expectations, labour market satisfaction, propensity to emigrate, trust

PhD, University Assistant Professor, Corvinus University of Budapest/Associate Lecturer, Babeș–Bolyai University/Vice President, Association of Hungarian Economists in Romania, e-mail: [email protected], [email protected]. 2 PhD student, Corvinus University of Budapest, e-mail: [email protected]. 3 PhD student, Corvinus University of Budapest, e-mail: [email protected]. 4 The authors would like to express their appreciation to the students of the Marketeam College in Cluj-Napoca who coordinated the research – Bernadett Farkas, Edina Halász, Tünde Magyari, Tünde Terdik, Ibolya Vizeli – for their outstanding work during the processing of the literature and the conduct of the data collection. Furthermore, the authors would like to thank the leaders of the National Hungarian Students' Association and the National Association of Hungarian Secondary School Students for their support in organising the questionnaire-based research.

Introduction

According to empirical research, one reason for the demographic decline of the Hungarian population in the Carpathian Basin can be found in economic uncertainty and an unpredictable labour market environment (Siskáné et al. 2017). This finding is particularly true for Hungarian communities living in territories outside of Hungary, where not only does minority status often result in negative discrimination in the labour market, but the turbulent changes in the political, economic, cultural, and regulatory environments of the surrounding countries also exacerbate employment difficulties and hinder successful labour market integration.

For Hungarian youths living in a minority to remain in their homeland, the development and perception of a stable, predictable labour market vision is a prerequisite. This is a critical criterion for the improvement of any socio-economic factor that is also decisive from a national strategic perspective, such as rising employment rates and wages, the filling of high-quality job positions, increasing job satisfaction, growing welfare and subjective well-being, a decrease in the propensity to emigrate, or an increase in the inclination to start a family (Vasile–Vasile 2011).

At the same time, the preparation of targeted social and economic interventions cannot overlook a scientific-level assessment of the attitudes and experiences of the affected Hungarian minority communities regarding labour market integration. In our research, we sought to explore the perceptions and preferences of local youths regarding the Romanian labour market situation within the most significant Hungarian community outside of Hungary, the Hungarians of Transylvania.

The comprehensive objectives of our research can be summarised as follows: * To provide a general snapshot of the labour market prospects, propensity to emigrate, and satisfaction with their labour market situation among Hungarian youths in Transylvania. * To assess the preferences, expectations, and experiences of Hungarian youths in Transylvania regarding employment and job selection (e.g. sector, organisational type, salary). * To assess and describe the trust of Hungarian youths in Transylvania towards Romanian labour market actors. * To assess the importance and attainment of the skills and competencies required for successful integration into the Romanian labour market, and to explore the supporting role of the school system in acquiring the necessary skills and competencies.

In contrast to previous empirical studies examining the labour market integration of youths (Csata 2017; Marginean 2014; Mocanu–Zamfir 2016; Pisica et al. 2015; Szanyi–Susánszky 2018; Székely 2018; Veres 2013, 2014, 2017), our research does not merely present the labour market situation of Hungarian youths in Transylvania from a classical socio-demographic perspective; rather, by involving numerous economic, business, and educational variables, it seeks answers to illustrate the impact of factors that promote or hinder the labour market integration of youths, thereby opening the possibility for the results to be utilised by a wide range of social stakeholders.

Literature Review

As a first step towards uncovering the social factors determining the labour market integration of Hungarian youths in Transylvania, we conducted an interdisciplinary literature review encompassing economics, sociology, education, and psychology. Following a processing of international and domestic studies published over recent decades examining the labour market situation of ethnic minorities (Constantine et al. 1998; Csata 2017, 2019; Froy–Pyne 2011; Lindermann 2009; Székely 2018; Veres 2013, 2014, 2017; Wentling–Waight 2001), we identified the under-researched aspects and the mixed and contradictory findings within the field, subsequently examining how we might contribute to the expansion of the existing body of knowledge. Furthermore, through structured content analysis based on defined criteria, we examined articles concerning the labour market integration of youths appearing in the Hungarian-language press in Transylvania, as well as blogs, forums, and groups on social media.

In our study, alongside the identification of factors determining individual labour market success, we treated the issue of migration as a key priority dependent variable. We justified our research objective by the need to maintain the historical integrity of Hungarian communities in Transylvania, as the correlation between labour market situation and the propensity to migrate has long been regarded as an accepted explanatory factor in this field (Horváth 2008b; Gosnell–Abrams 2011). Based on previous research, the difficulties of transitioning into adulthood, stable and secure labour market integration, and levels of income and broadly defined well-being may influence the propensity of youths to migrate (Horváth 2008b; Siskáné et al. 2017; Sandu et al. 2018; Vasile–Vasile 2011).

To establish a basis for examining the individual factors determining employment opportunities, we relied on studies that highlighted the correlations and discrepancies between labour market expectations and labour market satisfaction (Sutton–Griffin 2000; Vasile–Vasile 2011). It is a general finding that the labour market expectations of youths significantly determine their satisfaction, which manifests explicitly in their workplace well-being, the stability of their employment, and their level of loyalty to their employers (Sandu et al. 2018; Sutton–Griffin 2004; Vasile–Vasile 2011).

Examining the discrepancies between the expectations and practical experiences of employed youths (Bocsi–Kozák 2013) is particularly important because, based on the theory of Porter and Steers (1973), unfulfilled labour market expectations can have a negative impact on employee retention and individual well-being, thereby increasing the propensity to migrate.

In addition to the variables identified in the scientific literature, we paid particular attention to uncovering the sectoral and industry preferences of youths to ensure the practical utility of our study. According to previous academic investigations, the differences observable in these areas (e.g. domestic or international employers; manufacturing or service sectors; private or public sectors) may be particularly relevant to the formation of labour market satisfaction or the propensity to migrate regarding the gap between youths' expectations and their lived reality (AC Nielsen 2000; Székely 2018; Kerekes–Pakucs 2013). Moreover, the integration of these areas into our research was also justified by the general labour shortage that has become increasingly prevalent in Romania in recent years (Manea et al. 2019); as a result of this, many companies have initiated significant employer branding programmes (Mungiu 2019), and the ability to attract and retain young employees has become a critical success factor for corporate competitiveness (Ambler–Barrow 1996).

The successful countries of the 21st century are characterised by knowledge-based societies; thus, Central and Eastern European countries seeking to catch up are also striving to direct increasingly significant resources towards research and development and the modernisation of education (Szarowska 2018). Romania has also struggled for years with the transformation of its education system; meanwhile, the professional pillars, structure, and timing of this transformation are subject to regular pedagogical and political criticism, and the inadequate alignment between changing labour market demands and the knowledge acquired within the school system frequently becomes a subject of academic debate (Balan 2011; Ciuhureanu et al. 2014). It is our intuition that the acquisition of adequate competencies and skills is an indispensable condition for the successful labour market integration of Hungarian youths in Transylvania. This may be important at two levels: firstly, during labour selection, one of the most critical indicators of an individual lies in their knowledge and abilities (Brewer 2013). Furthermore, an inequality may emerge in which companies wishing to invest avoid certain sectors due to a lack of appropriate human resources; consequently, potential employees—owing to the lack of jobs—do not perceive the relevance of skill development, which is a key characteristic of less modern economies specialising in low value-added activities (Fieldsend 2011).

In examining environmental factors, we were interested in how actors influencing the labour market, such as educational institutions or regulatory bodies, might affect employees, for example, by mediating the gaps between expected and existing competencies (Ciuhureanu et al. 2014), which may also assist in identifying points for policy intervention.

In connection with the above, we approached the topics of labour market prospects, satisfaction, and the propensity to emigrate from the perspective of one of the most important environmental factors: social trust. It is a general European phenomenon that youth increasingly place less trust in the activities of various state institutions, but attitudes towards the roles played by actors in the market and civil spheres regarding the labour market are not necessarily positive among young people either (Keating–Thrandardottir 2017). At the same time, according to empirical studies, successful labour market integration can hardly be imagined without mutual trust and authentic dialogue between young people and various social institutions (Székely 2018).

In our research, we examine the labour market integration of an ethnic minority; thus, similar to previous studies (Bocsi 2018; Csata 2019), proficiency in the language of the majority society—in this case, the Romanian language—has also played an important role in our empirical research. Several Romanian and international articles highlight that written and conversational proficiency in the language of the majority society is essential for occupying high-quality job positions and joining outstanding workplace communities; thus, it significantly determines young people's labour market prospects, accessible income, satisfaction with their labour market situation, and propensity to emigrate (Grin–Vaillancourt 1997; Grin et al. 2014; Horváth 2008a). Several studies have already addressed the anomalies experienced by Hungarian schools in Transylvania regarding Romanian language instruction and the deficient Romanian language proficiency of Hungarian youths in Transylvania (Péntek 2009; Horváth 2003); therefore, the inclusion of this variable proved essential in our research focusing on the labour market integration of young people.

Applied research methodology

Based on the literature review presented in the previous chapter, we developed an initial conceptual model intended to illustrate the assumed relationships between our key independent and dependent variables. We endeavoured to refine this theoretical model through consultations with representatives from various groups relevant to the topic. Through more than 30 structured and semi-structured expert and in-depth interviews—conducted both in person and via online channels—we held exploratory discussions with Hungarian secondary school and university students in Transylvania, young professionals, teachers, parents, executives and HR staff of companies, career advisers, as well as journalists and researchers with decades of experience in studying young Hungarians in Transylvania. Consequently, our qualitative research, conducted in the second quarter of 2020, contributed significantly to refining the content elements of the subsequent questionnaire survey.

In the descriptive section of our primary research, a quantitative, large-scale questionnaire survey was conducted between June and August 2020. The preparation and implementation of the research were supported by the Marketeam College in Cluj-Napoca, as well as the National Union of Hungarian Students in Romania (OMDSZ) and the National Association of Hungarian Secondary School Students (MAKOSZ). As the latter two organisations have significant access to the target group of our research—Hungarians in Transylvania aged 16–30—our sampling procedure cannot be considered random, but merely non-probability (convenience) sampling.

The questionnaire was developed using the professional survey platform Qualtrics, and its link was distributed through the electronic channels of the Marketeam College, OMDSZ, and MAKOSZ. The sampling frame for the questionnaire survey was the membership and the number of followers on the respective online platforms of the three organisations, which amounted to approximately 20,000 young Hungarians in Transylvania. Participation was voluntary and anonymous, and respondents were incentivised to complete the survey in full with valuable prizes and unique identification codes. Completing the questionnaire took 15–20 minutes.

In operationalising the most important theoretical constructs of our research, we endeavoured to employ multi-item scales—often following a specific factor structure—that had been successfully utilised in previous studies and proven to be valid and reliable. For example, to map expectations regarding work and the workplace, as well as satisfaction with various workplace aspects, we relied on the items from scales used in the studies of Sutton–Griffin (2000; 2004) and Bocsi–Kozák (2013), adapting them to the specific regional context.

Similarly, to assess the general skills and abilities required for success in the labour market, we adapted the classification (importance and self-reported performance) and scale used in the AC Nielsen (2000) study.

In our questionnaire, most variables were assessed using a 5-point Likert scale, where a value of 1 represented options such as "not at all characteristic" or "not at all satisfied", while a value of 5 represented "completely characteristic" or "completely satisfied". When processing the survey data, in addition to presenting descriptive statistics illustrating the attitudes, opinions, and preferences of young people regarding the labour market, we treated it as a high priority to use multivariate mathematical-statistical methods to uncover similarities and differences between respondent groups with varying sociodemographic characteristics (Dag et al. 2018). This was performed using one-way ANOVA analyses and F-tests, with our hypotheses being accepted or rejected using a significance level of p=0.05.

We also placed emphasis on identifying the less and more strongly determining factors of the labour market prospects, general labour market satisfaction, and migration intentions of Hungarian youths in Transylvania. We endeavoured to perform this using linear regression analyses and OLS estimations. The reliability of our models was established at a significance level of p=0.05, while the proportion of variance in the dependent variable explained by all independent variables included in each model was quantified using the R² indicator (Hunyadi 2000). The effect of each individual independent variable on the dependent variable was examined via the coefficient (ß) of the given independent variable, which was tested at a significance level of p=0.05. In this article, we report only the results of those regression models in which the greatest number of independent variables were included for the purpose of explaining the variance of the dependent variable. The IBM SPSS 25.0 statistical software package was used to conduct our analyses.

Out of a gross total of 1584 respondents, 1323 respondents characterised by qualitative data provision were included in the analysis after filtering for various professional and statistical reasons, of whom 1033 completed the questionnaire in full. This means that the gross response rate in our research was nearly 8%, whereas calculated against the respondents included in the analysis, this proportion was more than 5%.

To interpret our results and draw our conclusions, we conducted 10 expos post interviews (Kvale 1996), in which we placed great emphasis on purposefully uncovering the causal relationships and potential explanations behind our more interesting research findings.

Composition of the respondent sample

More than half (52%) of the respondents included in the analysis (1323 individuals) belong to the 20–23 age group, indicating a fairly strong overrepresentation of this age cohort. The second highest participation group (25%) consists of 16–19-year-olds, mostly secondary school students and first-year university students who are facing career choice decisions. Those aged 24–26 and 27–30 collectively account for 23% of the respondents; members of this age group have most likely already survived the "crossfire" of entering the workforce and are employed, making their responses particularly interesting for assessing work experience and labour market satisfaction.

65% of the respondents are female and 35% are male. The overrepresentation of female respondents is consistent with the trend generally observed in questionnaire-based research; that is, we can speak of a deviation from the gender distribution of the target group of Hungarian youths in Transylvania, and thus this imbalance must be taken into account when interpreting the results.

One third of the questionnaire respondents live in villages or communes, one third in county seats, and the remainder is divided between small towns (20 per cent), large cities (13 per cent), and the capital, Bucharest (1%). These proportions somewhat reflect the settlement structure distribution of the Hungarian-speaking minority living in Romania, and within it in Transylvania, which is largely concentrated in smaller settlements and a few more important, medium-sized towns. In this respect, our respondent sample roughly represents the entire population.

In the category of marital status, the proportion of single respondents is the highest (44%), followed by those in cohabiting relationships (35%), then those in cohabiting relationships (16%); 5 per cent of respondents are married, and 1 respondent is divorced. 97 per cent of the respondents are childless, while three per cent have children.

Thirteen per cent of respondents are secondary school students, with a notably high proportion (41%) participating in undergraduate studies, 17% in master's programmes, and 1% in postgraduate studies. It is clearly evident that these figures partly run parallel to those of students in dual education, which is a significant factor in terms of representativeness, as highly qualified youths constitute a prominent sub-group in our research.

Among the respondents, 38% are those who regularly work at least 20 hours per week. It can also be observed that a further 20% of respondents work exclusively, while interestingly, 8% of respondents neither study nor work.

Regarding educational attainment, the characteristics previously examined can be observed once again. The proportions of those with an undergraduate degree (BA/BSc) and a master's degree (MA/MSc) are identical at 33% each, together accounting for two-thirds of the respondents. The remainder is distributed among those who completed gymnasium (2 per cent), lyceum (21 per cent), technical lyceum/vocational school (6 per cent), and post-secondary school (4 per cent). This further demonstrates that the research successfully reached primarily highly qualified youths; thus, those with lower levels of education are underrepresented in the respondent sample.

Given the geographical distribution of the Hungarian population in Romania, it is not surprising that the largest proportion of respondents (30.7%) originated from Harghita County. In the county-level distribution of respondents' origins, this is followed by Mureș (15%), Covasna (13.5%), Cluj (11.3%), Bihor (10.5%), and Satu Mare (8.6%).5 The remaining majority of respondents is distributed among the other counties characterised by Hungarian minority enclaves.

Regarding Romanian language proficiency, which is expected to play a significant role in the labour market integration of Hungarian youths in Transylvania, a total of 14% of respondents speak Romanian excellently (of which 4% at a native level and 10% perfectly). According to their own accounts, 33% speak well but with a noticeable accent; while this is not necessarily a poor proportion, it is evident that fewer than half of the respondents (47%) speak the majority language at least well. The remaining proportions are as follows: in the majority of cases, 36% can make themselves understood in Romanian, 16% can make themselves understood with difficulty, and 2% speak almost no Romanian at all. Interestingly, despite such low Romanian language proficiency, the majority of respondents were drawn from the more highly qualified segments of the age group. 5 For comparison, the distribution of the Hungarian-speaking population in the aforementioned counties is provided here, based on a projection for 2020 derived from the 2011 census (Kiss–Csata 2016): Harghita (21.55%), Mureș (16.75%), Covasna (12.5%), Cluj (8.2%), Bihor (12%), and Satu Mare (11%).

Overall, it can be stated that the composition of our respondent sample cannot be considered representative, as those with higher educational attainment, women, and non-working youths are overrepresented compared to the total 16–30 age group; however, in terms of county of origin and settlement structure, the composition of the sample closely approximates the general distribution.

Labour market prospects of Hungarian youths in Transylvania

Despite the dynamic development experienced by the Romanian economy in recent years, 36% of the surveyed Hungarian youths in Transylvania view their labour market prospects in Romania as unfavourable. Furthermore, 48% consider them acceptable, 14% good, and 2% excellent. On a scale of 1 to 5, where 1 represents very poor and 5 represents excellent, respondents gave an average score of 2.8 regarding their Romanian labour market prospects. Thus, Hungarian youths in Transylvania continue to perceive their labour market prospects in Romania as rather poor.

Subsequently, we employed analysis of variance (ANOVA) to determine whether significant differences exist in the perception of Romanian labour market prospects among respondents with varying socio-demographic characteristics.

We found significant differences in the perception of labour market prospects based on the respondents' gender, educational attainment, employment status, salary level, and place of residence. It can be stated that women view their labour market prospects less favourably than men (2.69 and 2.94, respectively), while those in employment assess their prospects more positively than those not working (2.85 and 2.73). Those with higher salaries also view their labour market prospects more favourably (from 3.55 to 2.27), as do youths with better proficiency in the Romanian language (2.96 and 2.20). Youths working in Bucharest hold more positive views regarding their labour market prospects than those living elsewhere (3.27 and 2.58).

No significant differences were found regarding labour market prospects between respondents of different ages or marital statuses, nor did whether the respondent had children influence the assessment of prospects.

Numerous regression models were constructed to examine which factors might have significantly or less significantly influenced the development of youths' labour market prospects. We observed that when examining only the impact of work-related expectations and trust on the perception of general labour market prospects, our regression model was significant, yet its explanatory power was relatively low (12.5%). Interestingly, the assessment of the role played by the education system—in acquiring the skills necessary for labour market success—did not provide additional explanatory power in predicting prospects.

However, when we integrated general satisfaction with one's labour market situation as an independent variable into our model examining the development of labour market prospects, the explanatory power of the model increased significantly (42.2%).

Among the work-related expectations, the strongest explanatory variables were the extent of advancement opportunities provided by the workplace (coefficient $\beta = 0.114$); within the dimension of trust, trust in Romanian employees ($\beta = 0.220$), trust in the preparatory work of educational actors ($\beta = -0.114$), and trust in the services provided by career counselling companies ($\beta = -0.107$), the latter of which negatively impacted the assessment of youths' labour market prospects.

The strongest explanatory factor in the model for predicting labour market prospects proved to be the respondents' general labour market satisfaction ($\beta = 0.526$).

Work- and employment-related expectations

General expectations regarding employment

Regarding detailed expectations related to workplaces, young respondents indicated the level of importance for 16 criteria on a scale ranging from 1 to 5, based on Sutton–Griffin (2000; 2004), where 1 represented 'not important at all' and 5 represented 'very important'. Based on these, the three most important expectations held by Hungarian youths in Transylvania were that there should be time for family alongside work (4.47), that the job should be fully registered (4.39), and the degree of stability and reliability of the workplace (4.36), while the factors deemed least important were the accessibility of the workplace (3.65), the level of effort required to perform the work (3.76), and the personality of the boss (3.8).

Preferred sector

In addition to the youths' labour market and workplace expectations, we also inquired about two important factors: their preferred sectors and the preferred organisational type and size of the workplace. In the case of respondents who are already employed, these questions were posed regarding their current workplace. As the questions applied to two different respondent groups, a direct comparison cannot be made; however, interesting insights can be drawn from the results regarding the differences between the sectors and workplaces preferred by young people and those that actually employ them.

In the case of young people not currently in employment, it can be seen (Figure 1) that healthcare and social assistance (15%), education, research and development (12%), and the IT sector (10%) are the most popular preferred sectors, whereas employment is least popular in the transport, storage and warehousing (1%), mining and manufacturing (1%), and energy and utilities (1%) sectors.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

As can be seen from Figure 4, during the period of the survey, the majority of employed young people worked for domestically owned micro, small, or medium-sized enterprises (42%), followed by foreign-owned large corporations (19%) and state-owned enterprises, public administration offices, or other state institutions (e.g. hospitals, schools, social institutions, etc.) (10%). Furthermore, 8% worked for domestically owned large private corporations, 7% for foreign-owned micro, small, or medium-sized enterprises, 6% for non-profit organisations, 4% in their own businesses, and 1% in religious institutions.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Among the discrepancies between preferences and reality, the most striking is the gap between the relatively high entrepreneurial inclination (3.9) and the low entrepreneurial rate (4%). It is also important to highlight the overrepresentation of foreign large enterprises (19%) and state employers (10%) relative to expectations. According to both approaches, religious institutions are by far the least popular (an average of 2.42 and 1%). Uncovering the factors explaining the occurrence of these phenomena could constitute a promising subject for future research.

We deemed it important to examine whether significant differences exist between groups of young respondents with differing sociodemographic characteristics regarding their inclination to seek employment in various organisational types.

In the case of entrepreneurial inclination, those with lower language proficiency showed less preference for this option, although in this instance the results were not statistically significant. Interestingly, entrepreneurial inclination was higher among those with children than among those without (4.44 vs. 3.89). Those living in the county seat are less inclined to work in their own business (3.68) than those living in small settlements, small towns, or large towns (approx. 4.00), while respondents from different counties also exhibit varying levels of entrepreneurial inclination. Regarding domestic SMEs, a trend can be observed where the inclination to work in these organisations is also higher in older age groups. This is consistent with the fact that secondary school students (3.36) show a lower inclination towards working in such organisations compared to the overall average of 3.79. It is also noteworthy that women (3.86) would be more willing to work at domestic SMEs than men (3.65), and that those in relationships or marriages also show a higher inclination (3.87 and 4.05), as do university graduates (4.00–4.06). An interesting finding is that settlement type and county of origin had no effect on preferences regarding domestic SMEs.

Regarding the inclination to seek employment in foreign-owned SMEs, significant differences were only observed between those with university and non-university qualifications (3.85 vs. 2.67). In the case of domestic large enterprises, it is significant that respondents with higher Romanian language proficiency also show a higher inclination to work in similar organisations (3.89).

Interestingly, compared to young people pursuing university studies (3.68–4.75), the inclination to seek employment at domestic large enterprises is strikingly low among those who are exclusively employed (3.2).

In the case of foreign large enterprises, it can also be observed that those with higher language proficiency show a greater inclination to seek employment in similar organisations (3.70–3.80); furthermore, the average rating among those living in villages and communes (3.28) is significantly lower than the total group average (3.45).

Regarding the inclination to seek employment in state institutions, a significant difference was experienced only in terms of gender, with women being more willing to imagine themselves (3.47) in the public sector than men (3.11).

Regarding employment in religious institutions, two non-significant factors showed striking values: type of settlement—rated higher in villages and communes—and language proficiency, where those with a higher level of Romanian language skills exhibited a lower propensity for employment in similar organisations. Similar to state institutions, women (3.46) found the non-profit sector more attractive than men (3.27). Interestingly, those in relationships or cohabiting show relatively high values (3.69) regarding employment in non-profit organisations for some reason.

Expected and actual salary

One of the variables that enjoyed significant interest from both labour market actors and the youth was salary. In the questionnaire, we asked Hungarian youths in Transylvania about their expected starting salary, the current actual salary of employed youths, and we sought to ascertain from both respondent groups what monthly income they aspire to achieve after 10 years of work experience.

In all cases, respondents were asked to provide net amounts.

44% of non-working youths would prefer a net starting salary of 2001–3000 lei at their first job; despite the dominance of higher education among respondents, this is approximately 30–40% higher than actual starting salaries according to the surveyed labour market experts. It is noteworthy that 4% of non-working youths would prefer a net starting salary exceeding 5000 lei, whereas approximately 1/3 of respondents represent the national "reality", which corresponds to selecting the 1361–2000 lei option.

It is worthwhile to compare the somewhat ambitious expectations of non-working youths regarding starting salaries with the actual income of employed Hungarian youths in Transylvania. The responses indicate that the actual net earnings of 49% of employed Transylvanian youths do not exceed 2000 lei. Furthermore, 32% of employed youths earn a net amount between 2001–3000 lei. Only 4% of respondents had a net salary of 5000 lei. In comparison, in 2020, the gross minimum wage in Romania was 2230 lei, while the gross average wage was 5565 lei, with net values of 1668 and 4161 lei respectively; this means that the official wages of the vast majority of Hungarian youths in Transylvania do not reach the level of the Romanian average wage. The discrepancy between desired and actual salaries is exacerbated by the fact that actual salaries inherently and decisively comprise more than just entry-level earnings.

According to 37% of Hungarian youths in Transylvania (employed and non-employed combined), the ideal salary they wish to achieve after 10 years of work experience lies within the 4001–6500 lei net salary range. A more realistic 33% stated that they would like a salary between 2501–4000 lei after gaining 10 years of professional experience. Interestingly, 8% of respondents would consider a net salary exceeding 10,000 lei justified after 10 years of work experience, which, as an employee, appears plausible in Romania in only a few sectors (e.g., IT, healthcare, commerce, the entrepreneurial sector).

The results indicate that managing the wage-related expectations of Hungarian youths in Transylvania—in a conscious manner that does not stifle ambition or readiness to act—is one of the most critical tasks for educational and labour market actors, as well as families and other micro-communities (e.g. friends). This is because income that does not align with talent, qualifications, professional training, personal knowledge, and competencies is a significant factor in the disillusionment and decline in subjective well-being among young people, which may even increase labour market dissatisfaction and the propensity to emigrate.

General satisfaction with the labour market

The degree of general satisfaction with the Romanian labour market was examined only among respondents who were working at the time of the survey, i.e., those possessing primary work experience. On a Likert scale ranging from 1 to 5, taking every factor into account, working respondents rated their labour market satisfaction in Romania at an average of 3.1. Only 36% of respondents were satisfied with their current workplace (9% being completely satisfied and 27% rather satisfied), 35% were neither satisfied nor dissatisfied, 19% were rather dissatisfied, and 9% were not satisfied at all.

According to the literature, the general labour market satisfaction of young people is driven to a significant extent by satisfaction with professional, personal, and other aspects and dimensions related to their workplace (Sutton–Griffin 2000). Based on this, an examination of workplace satisfaction in detail reveals that the three workplace aspects with which respondents were most satisfied were the degree of official designation of their current position (4.24), the friendliness of their colleagues (4.08), and the accessibility of their workplace (4.04). Conversely, the three workplace factors with which they were least satisfied were opportunities for advancement (3.28), received salary (3.29), and the degree of participation in organisational decision-making (3.33).

It is evident that the aspects achieving lower satisfaction averages are significantly closer to the overall average (3.1): the difference between the highest-rated workplace aspect and the overall average is 1.14, whereas in the case of the lowest-rated aspect, the difference is 0.18. This is consistent with the methodological characteristics of most similar research, which suggests that once a general negative attitude towards a phenomenon is "unpacked", the assessment of individual detailed aspects is much more favourable than the assessment of the general overall picture (Malhotra 2008).

An interesting correlation is that, in the case of positively rated factors, there is no discernible order; one aspect relates to the legal circumstances of the workplace, one to the internal social conditions of the workplace, and one to its physical characteristics. In contrast, all negatively assessed aspects can, in some form, be linked to a lack of personal or professional recognition at the workplace, which may indicate a relative disappointment compared to expectations.

Regarding general workplace satisfaction, we also examined whether significant differences exist between respondent groups with different socio-demographic characteristics. Among the comparisons examined, the most notable differences were those based on received salary (average workplace satisfaction was 2.60 at the lowest pay level and 4.05 at the highest), gender (3.05 and 3.25 in favour of men), and Romanian language proficiency (average satisfaction was 1.78 at the lowest proficiency level, while for perfect and native-level proficiency, satisfaction was 3.30 and 3.22, respectively).

A significant difference was observed regarding educational attainment; those who completed technical high school/vocational school were significantly more satisfied with their current workplace (3.07–3.38) than those who completed grammar school, high school, or post-secondary education (2.42–2.90). As expected, place of residence is also correlated with the level of job satisfaction, as Hungarian youths living in villages/communes and small towns (2.94–2.92) are less satisfied with their jobs than those living in county seats, large cities, or Bucharest (3.18–3.40).

Regarding the variables of current status, presence of children, age, marital status, and county of origin, no significant differences could be identified among employed Hungarian youths in Transylvania in terms of general labour market satisfaction.

In the case of general job satisfaction, we also attempted to identify the impact of the factors determining satisfaction using several linear regression models.

The model containing satisfaction with individual workplace aspects as independent variables was significant and explained 33% of the variance in the general labour market satisfaction of employed Hungarian youths in Transylvania. After including trust in various labour market institutions among our independent variables estimating general satisfaction, the explanatory power of the predictive model for satisfaction increased to 37.1%.

The additional explanatory power of our model estimating general job satisfaction increased substantially following the integration of the assessment of labour market prospects as an independent variable (R²=50.6%), which we had also anticipated based on our previously identified correlation. Interestingly, satisfaction with the extent of support provided by the school system—in terms of acquiring knowledge and skills—did not contribute significantly to the pattern of general job satisfaction.

It can be stated that the strongest explanatory variables in the pattern of general satisfaction are the general assessment of future labour market prospects (ß=0.430), satisfaction with received salary (ß=0.178), satisfaction with the extent of official registration of employment (ß=0.095), as well as, with an opposing effect, trust in Romanian workers (ß=-0.119) and trust in the work of occupational health and safety organisations (ß=-0.104). Our findings clearly highlight the mutual correlation between labour market prospects (expectations) and job satisfaction (experiences): Hungarian youths in Transylvania with positive prospects are more satisfied with their jobs, while respondents who are more satisfied with their jobs also assess their future labour market prospects more favourably.

Comparison of workplace expectations and job satisfaction: In the case of employed Hungarian youths in Transylvania (n=482), the application of the Sutton–Griffin (2004) scale allowed us to compare the extent to which workplace expectations align with experienced satisfaction regarding various workplace aspects. Unsurprisingly, the greatest discrepancy was observed regarding received salary, as this received quite high priority (4.37) among workplace expectations, whereas the satisfaction of working youths with the income earned at their workplace was only 3.29; thus, they rated their satisfaction with their salary 1.08 points lower than their expectations.

Significant differences can still be observed between workplace expectations and satisfaction with individual aspects of the job regarding promotion opportunities (1.01), the development of skills and competencies (0.95), value-creating and useful tasks (0.83), time spent with family (0.82), and the respect and recognition received (0.78). Interestingly, the accessibility of the workplace, which young workers in Transylvania considered the least important (3.62), received a satisfaction rating that was actually 0.66 higher in practice; thus, this was the only workplace factor that was rated more positively than the expectations.

Expectations and satisfaction aligned most closely regarding the level of effort required for the work, with a difference of 0.12 in favour of expectations.

It is also important to highlight the values of the two highest-rated variables alongside time spent with family: in the case of work visibility, a difference of 0.19 can be seen, while in the case of stability, the difference was 0.47; in both instances, working respondents considered the factors somewhat more important than their level of satisfaction with them.

Migration propensity

Regarding one of the most important constructs of our research, it can be stated that—contrary to expectations and the perceived general mood—61 per cent of the surveyed young Hungarians in Transylvania do not plan to move abroad for longer than one year. On a scale of 1 to 5—where a value of 1 means not at all likely and 5 means completely likely—the average migration propensity was 2.3. For 23% of respondents, migration is likely but not certain; for 9%, it is more than likely; and for 6%, migration is a certainty. Thus, the proportion of young people who fundamentally wish to leave their country for longer than one year is only 15%. One explanatory factor for this may be the previously mentioned high level of respondent education or the absence of young people who may have already emigrated during the sampling process.

Through variance analysis, we endeavoured to uncover significant differences in the migration propensity of young respondents with differing sociodemographic characteristics. Based on Figure 5, significant differences can be detected regarding current status, as the migration propensity of those participating in university postgraduate training is considerably lower (2.00) than that of secondary school students (2.52) or their peers who are neither studying nor working (2.41). It can also be demonstrated that those with regular employment are also less likely to plan to leave their homeland (2.17) than their non-working peers (2.31), while, in accordance with our expectations, those with children plan to move abroad for longer periods almost not at all (1.47), compared to the average migration propensity of those without children (2.29).

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Interestingly, regarding the propensity to emigrate, no differences were observed among respondents based on current salary levels, educational attainment, gender, place of residence/settlement type, level of Romanian language proficiency, or county of origin.

We employed regression models to attempt to identify which factors contribute strongly or weakly to the formation of young people's propensity to emigrate. Overall, it can be concluded that although our models were significant, their explanatory power proved to be very limited, even after including the independent variables potentially available to us. Interestingly, the general assessment of labour market prospects explained only 3 per cent of the variance in the propensity to emigrate; even after including various aspects of work- and employment-related expectations as independent variables, this explanatory power rose to only 4 per cent, and reached 5.5 per cent upon the integration of trust in labour market actors. Subsequently, we attempted to further increase the explanatory power of our model using respondents' statements regarding general satisfaction with their labour market situation and detailed satisfaction with workplace aspects, but even with the integration of these variables, we succeeded in predicting the propensity to emigrate among young people in only 11.3 per cent of cases.

The results of our complex regression model are illustrated in Table 1, which quantifies the impact of potentially explanatory statements on the propensity to emigrate. Based on this, the factors most determinative of the propensity to emigrate among Hungarian youths in Transylvania proved to be the expectation of friendliness of colleagues (ß=0.124), the expected level of respect and recognition received during work (ß= -0.143), the expected level of effort required to perform the work (ß= -0.116), the expected reliability of the workplace (ß=-0.130), as well as job stability (ß=-0.111), the extent of workplace feedback (ß=-0.101), satisfaction with the advancement opportunities offered by the workplace (ß=0.136), and the general assessment of Romanian labour market prospects (ß=-0.163).

Interestingly, the expectation regarding the friendliness of colleagues and the propensity to emigrate were positively correlated, suggesting that young people considering emigration would most likely realise this within a friendly workplace community. Similarly, it is interesting that an increase in satisfaction with workplace advancement opportunities did not decrease, but rather increased the propensity to emigrate, which also highlights that working Transylvanian youths who are hesitant about emigration plan to achieve this within a framework of favourable workplace conditions.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Trust in labour market actors

We examined the level of trust in actors and institutions that influence labour market placement using a scale ranging from 1 to 5, where the endpoints were the response alternatives "1 = I do not trust at all" and "5 = I trust completely". Regarding trust in relation to the success of labour market integration and the propensity to emigrate, it can be stated that, taking all factors into account, respondents placed less trust in Romanian labour market actors, with an average trust level of 2.93.

Based on the data, Hungarian youths in Transylvania placed the least trust in the activities of state institutions related to the labour market (trust in government 2.56; trust in the judiciary 2.54). Respondents demonstrated a somewhat higher level of trust in educational actors (2.85); however, it should be noted that the question did not refer exclusively to state-maintained institutions. This is corroborated by the fact that youths showed the relatively highest trust in institutions outside the traditional school system (3.46), such as language schools, programming schools, or organisations providing preparatory courses and training. This highlights the significant opportunities for such organisations, particularly their perceived or actual competitive advantage over traditional, formal educational institutions.

We also searched for significant differences between respondent groups with differing sociodemographic characteristics regarding the level of trust in individual labour market institutions and actors. We found that, overall, employed youths demonstrate significantly lower trust in labour market institutions—particularly state bodies and educational actors—than non-working youths.

In parallel, a correlation can also be observed between trust and the variables of current status and age, as the general trust of those who are no longer studying, are older, and are typically already working, proved to be lower compared to their younger peers, who are predominantly still participating in education. Interestingly, we did not observe significant differences in the level of trust in individual labour market actors with respect to county of origin, the presence of children, or place of residence/settlement type and level of Romanian language proficiency.

Upon closer examination regarding trust in Romanian employers and employees, we observed that trust is higher among those in an employment relationship (3.09 and 3.00 towards employers, and 3.11 and 3.09 towards employees). In the case of trust in other actors, those in an employment relationship showed lower values to varying degrees, but without exception: towards government labour market measures (2.36 and 2.67); towards judicial labour market measures (2.35 and 2.65); towards educational actors (2.66 and 2.95); towards actors outside the school system (3.38 and 3.59); towards career counselling companies (2.71 and 3.08); and towards occupational safety organisations (2.64 and 3.04).

Regarding the current status, we can observe that, in the case of trust in Romanian workers alone, no significant difference was found among respondents. The lowest trust values are typically observed among those who are currently not studying but are employed, who are significantly more distrustful compared to other respondent groups (e.g., secondary school and university students): regarding government labour market measures (2.27); regarding judicial labour market measures (2.30); regarding educational actors (2.61); regarding non-formal education actors (3.38); regarding career counselling firms (2.75); and regarding occupational safety and health organisations (2.61). It is striking that, in contrast to the labour market activities of non-formal education actors, we observed relatively high average trust ratings.

It is noteworthy in the status analysis that in two instances for those participating in postgraduate university education—regarding government labour market measures (2.70) and judicial labour market measures (3.00)—as well as in two instances for those participating in undergraduate university education—regarding non-formal education actors (3.59) and occupational safety and health organisations (3.03)—they reported significantly higher levels of trust than their peers of different statuses.

In terms of age, we found that the older the respondent, the less they trust various labour market institutions. As an example, trust in government labour market measures is exceptionally low in the 30-year-old age group (1.79), whereas for 20-year-olds, this figure is 2.73; furthermore, trust in judicial labour market measures is lowest among 30-year-olds (2.21), while it is significantly higher among 20 and 21-year-olds (2.75). Similarly, trust in educational actors is very low among 30-year-olds, whereas responses from the 20-year-old age group show the highest level of trust (3.06), as is the case with career counselling firms, towards which 30-year-olds are more distrustful (2.47) compared to the 20-year-old age group (3.21). This correlation can also be observed in the development of trust in occupational safety and health organisations, where the lowest level was produced by respondents aged 27 to 29 (2.55), while the highest was recorded among 20-year-olds (3.06).

Significant differences regarding trust in individual labour market actors were discovered between men and women in only three instances.

Men trust Romanian employers to a greater extent (3.11) than women (2.99), and women's level of trust is higher regarding the labour market measures of non-formal education actors (3.50 vs. 3.37) and towards career counselling firms (3.00 vs. 2.83).

Skills and the impact of the school system

Our research has proven to be an interesting field in exploring which knowledge, skills, and abilities Hungarian youths in Transylvania consider important for succeeding in the Romanian labour market. On a scale of 1 to 5 (1 – not important at all, 5 – extremely important), respondents rated flexibility and the ability to adapt to various situations (4.40), openness to acquiring new things (e.g. new technologies) (4.40), and efficient time management (4.38) as the most important. According to Hungarian youths in Transylvania, the least necessary skills for successful labour market integration are the ability to inspire and motivate others (3.98), as well as quantitative analysis skills (4.04) and the ability to find creative, original solutions in various situations (4.15). It is noteworthy that the difference between the averages of the skills/abilities deemed least and most important by the youths was only 0.42. The importance of skills and abilities is illustrated in Figures 6 and 7.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Table or figure – see the PDF version of the issue for its exact content.

Assessment of the role of the school system

Our young respondents also assessed the extent to which they believe the Romanian school system (comprising primary, secondary, and higher education institutions) supports the acquisition of skills and competencies necessary for labour market success. Taking all factors into account, we received an average rating of 2.69 on a Likert scale ranging from 1 to 5 (1 – does not support at all and 5 – supports fully) for this question, which indicates dissatisfaction among Hungarian youths in Transylvania with the Romanian school system. According to the respondents, 7% of young people believe the Romanian school system does not support it at all, 31% believe it rather does not support it, 50% believe it neither supports nor does not support it, furthermore, only 11% believe it rather supports it, and only 1 per cent think that it fully supports the acquisition of the competencies required for labour market success.

Based on the assessment of the school system's support in the acquisition of skills necessary for labour market success, we also searched for significant differences between the various respondent groups. We established that respondents currently pursuing secondary education and those who are currently only working assess the support of the school system lower (2.55 and 2.59) than their peers who are currently participating in higher education or working alongside their studies (2.66–3.00). Based on this, it is not surprising that Transylvanian youths with work experience assessed the support of the school system lower than non-working respondents (2.63 vs. 2.73). Interestingly, those who speak Romanian neither at all nor at a native level assessed the support of the school system as the most inadequate (2.31 and 2.48), compared to their peers who speak Romanian at an "intermediate" level (2.68–2.80).

It can also be observed that those living in the capital and county seats assess the school system's preparatory activities for the labour market as weaker (2.55–2.57) than those living in villages/communes, small towns, or large towns (2.70–2.80).

We also discovered significant differences among respondents based on age; it can be observed that those aged 18–28 assess the school system's contribution to the acquisition of competencies necessary for labour market success higher (2.58–2.93) than those aged 16–17 and 29–30 (2.41–2.58). A significant finding is that women assessed the extent of the school system's support higher (2.74) than men (2.60).

In the assessment of the school system's support, we found no differences based on marital status, parental status, county of origin, or, interestingly, current salary.

We used multivariate regression to examine to what extent the importance attributed to individual skills and competencies, and the degree of their self-reported proficiency, determine the opinions of young respondents regarding the school system's supporting role in the acquisition of labour market skills and competencies. Contrary to our expectations, although both models proved to be significant, their explanatory power was weak. The model examining the contribution of the importance of individual competencies had an explanatory power of only 1.9 per cent, while the self-reported proficiency of various skills contributed only 3.87 per cent to the formation of the assessment of the school system's support.

In the model examining the importance of individual competencies, the following skills contributed significantly to the prediction of the school system's support:

“Excellent cooperation with peers as a good team player” ($\beta$=0.068), “Finding creative and ingenious solutions in various situations” ($\beta$=0.084), “Strategic thinking and planning” ($\beta$=-0.081), “Quantitative analytical skills (calculation, estimation, forecasting)” ($\beta$=0.094). Furthermore, in a regression model examining the self-reported proficiency of various skills, the statements “I cooperate excellently with my peers as a good team player” ($\beta$=0.075), “I am able to inspire and motivate others” ($\beta$=0.135), “I logically construct cause-and-effect relationships during my arguments” ($\beta$=-0.084), “My quantitative analytical skills are well-developed” ($\beta$=0.099), and “I am excellent at creating and nurturing relationships with others” ($\beta$=0.075) significantly explained the variance experienced in the assessment of support for the school system.

Based on our findings, it can therefore be stated that, contrary to expectations, the perceived importance attributed to individual skills and abilities, alongside their self-reported proficiency, had a negligible influence on the assessment of the school system's role in acquiring labour market skills and competencies.

Conclusions

Our research experiences have revealed that the propensity of Hungarian youths in Transylvania to emigrate is low, contrary to our expectations. The propensity to emigrate among youths who are employed, or perhaps have already started a family, is significantly lower than that of their peers; therefore, the school system, employers, and other labour market institutions must play a prominent role in supporting the rapid employment of Hungarian youths in Transylvania, as this could mitigate the demographic retreat of Hungarian communities in Transylvania.

According to our results, a discrepancy exists between the labour market expectations of young people and their work experience; differences between importance and satisfaction regarding workplace aspects are most observable in terms of salary, professional development, opportunities for advancement, and personal appreciation. On this basis, it can be argued that the school system, labour market actors, and family and social networks must play a more decisive role in the conscious management of expectations, as the workplace “well-being” of young people is one of the fundamental pillars for avoiding a sense of disappointment and remaining in their homeland. Differences can be observed between the employment preferences of young people (sector, organisational type) and the actual sectoral and organisational distribution of employment. In the future, the school system, labour market actors, and policymakers must focus particular attention on: 1. creating favourable working conditions for young people in those sectors in which they would prefer to work; 2. ensuring that the professional structure of education partially adapts to the structural changes occurring in the Romanian economy; and 3. developing the knowledge and skills necessary for employment in sectors that are attractive from an employment perspective.

One of the key policy implications of our latter finding remains the necessary reform of Romanian language instruction in the educational institutions of Hungarian communities, as confident proficiency in the Romanian language is an indispensable condition for occupying high value-added job positions and achieving the associated high wages. According to our results, young people who speak Romanian at a high level are significantly more satisfied with their current labour market situation and assess their Romanian labour market prospects much more favourably than their peers who do not speak the country's official language.

This is particularly important for improving the situation of the Hungarian minority, as in recent decades, a large proportion of young people have studied vocations (humanities, pedagogy, writer, poet, social worker, journalist) whose financial and social appreciation has significantly declined, thereby reducing the satisfaction and existential security of these employee groups.

The level of trust directed towards labour market institutions and actors is low; however, this had only a minor impact on the propensity to emigrate, the assessment of labour market prospects, and satisfaction. Nevertheless, it is noteworthy that our survey revealed low levels of trust not only in state actors but also in employers and employees (potential colleagues), a phenomenon that is certainly observable among the companies and employees of the Hungarian community as well. Therefore, the conscious improvement of positive attitudes, authentic dialogue, and exemplary labour market behaviour is also an important task in order to strengthen trust within the Hungarian economic community.

Although our research aimed at a thorough analysis of a wide range of variables, it is naturally characterised by several theoretical and methodological shortcomings. Firstly, it should be noted that the respondent sample is not representative; thus, the results can only be interpreted with particular caution as generalisations applicable to the entire Hungarian youth population in Transylvania. Despite all our methodological efforts, we were unable to significantly predict the propensity to emigrate, or the support provided by the school system in the acquisition of labour market skills and competencies, using the set of variables at our disposal; therefore, it will be necessary to incorporate additional variables in future research. Due to scope limitations, we did not have the opportunity in our current questionnaire to examine exactly which skills and competencies the Romanian school system provides insufficient or outstanding support for; thus, for the sake of the policy relevance of our study, it is certainly advisable to address this in a subsequent study.

Further reflection is required to uncover why the assessment of the school system's role in the acquisition of skills and competencies did not possess significant additional explanatory power in predicting important dependent variables such as labour market prospects, general labour market satisfaction, or the propensity to emigrate. In connection with the above, we can conclude that, in addition to the socio-economic variables employed in the present study, it would be worthwhile to integrate individual-level factors—such as personality, aspirations, values, and social connections—into our future empirical research, as these may possess further significant explanatory power regarding the development of our most important dependent variables.

Finally, the possibility of conducting longitudinal or perhaps panel studies may arise to track changes in the opinions and preferences of Hungarian youth in Transylvania regarding labour market factors and actors, as well as to monitor the temporal evolution of the factors determining the propensity to emigrate, labour market prospects, and satisfaction.

Bibliography

References

  1. AC Nielsen Research Services. 2000. Employer satisfaction with graduate skills: research report. Evaluations and Investigations Programme, no. 99/7. Canberra: Department of Employment, Education, Training and Youth Affairs.
  2. Ambler, T.–Barrow, S. 1996. The Employer Brand. Journal of Brand Management 4, 185–206.
  3. Balan, M. 2011. Youth Employment On The Romanian Labour Market In The Context Of The Current Economic And Financial Crisis. Annals of Spiru Haret University, Economic Series 2(1), 101–112.
  4. Bocsi, V. 2018. (Kárpát-medencei) Erőforrástérkép: magyar fiatalok az oktatás világában. In: Székely, L. (szerk.) Magyar fiatalok a Kárpát-medencében: Magyar Ifjúság
  5. Kutatás 2016. Budapest: Enigma 2001 Kiadó, 183–204.
  6. Bocsi, V.–Kozák, A. 2013. Munkaértékek a felsőoktatásban: egy gender szempontú vizsgálat tanulságai. In: Móré, M. (szerk.) Társadalomtudományi Tanulmányok VI. Menedzsment tanulmányok. Debrecen: Debreceni Egyetemi Kiadó.
  7. Brewer, L. 2013. Enhancing youth employability: What? Why? and How? Guide to Core Work Skills. Geneva: International Labour Office.
  8. Ciuhureanu, A. T.–Fuciu, M.–Gorski, H. 2014. Identification of the labour market trends from the perspective of the competences and the skills requested as well as the recruitment sources used by the employers from the “Centre” development region. Annals of the University of Petroşani, Economics 14, 19–30.
  9. Constantine, M. G.–Erickson, C. D.–Banks, R. W.–Timberlake, T. L. 1998. Challenges to the Career Development of Urban Racial and Ethnic Minority Youth: Implications for Vocational Intervention. Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development 26(2), 83–95.
  10. Csata, Zs. 2017. Munkaerőpiaci egyenlőtlenségek Romániában, etnikai metszetben. Erdélyi Társadalom 15(1), 81–104.
  11. Csata, Zs. 2019. Gazdaság és etnicitás: Etnikai párhuzamosságok az erdélyi gazdaságban. Régió 27(1), 37–80.
  12. Dag, O.–Dolgun, A.–Konar, N. M. 2018. Onewaytests: An R Package for One-Way Tests in Independent Groups Designs. The R Journal 10(1), 175–199.
  13. Fieldsend, A. 2011. Rural Europe 2+2+: A conceptual framework for a rural employment policy. Studies in Agricultural Economics 113, 145–151.
  14. Froy, F.–Pyne, L. 2011. Ensuring Labour Market Success for Ethnic Minority and Immigrant Youth. OECD Local Economic and Employment Development (LEED) Working Papers. OECD Publishing.
  15. Gosnell, H.–Abrams, J. 2011. Amenity migration: Diverse conceptualizations of drivers, socioeconomic dimensions, and emerging challenges. GeoJournal 76(4), 303–322.
  16. Grin, F.–Marácz, L.–Pokorn, N. K.–Kraus, P. A. 2014. Mobility and Inclusion in Multilingual Europe: A Position Paper on the MIME Project. https://www.mime-project. org/resources/MIME-POSITION-PAPER-V4.pdf, letöltve: 2022. 12. 05.
  17. Grin, F.–Vaillancourt, F. 1997. The Economics of Multilingualism: Overview and Analytical Framework. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics 17, 43–65.
  18. Horváth, I. 2003. Az erdélyi magyarok kétnyelvűsége: nyelvmentés és integráció között? Erdélyi magyar társadalom 1(1), 7–23.
  19. Horváth, I. 2008a. Elemzések a romániai magyarok kétnyelvűségéről. Műhelytanulmányok a romániai kisebbségekről 8. Kolozsvár: Nemzeti Kisebbségkutató Intézet.
  20. Horváth, I. 2008b. The Culture of Migration of Rural Romanian Youth. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 34(5), 771–786.
  21. Hunyadi, L. 2000. A determinációs együtthatóról. Statisztikai szemle 78(9), 753–765.
  22. Keating, V. C.–Thrandardottir, E. 2017. NGOs, trust, and the accountability agenda. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 19(1), 134–151.
  23. Kerekes, K.–Pakucs, B. 2013. Occupational Choices of Romanian Rural Youth. Eastern European Countryside 19(1), 57–76.
  24. Kiss, T.–Csata, I 2016. Demographic perspectives. A projection of the Hungarianspeaking population of Transylvania for the time period between 2011 and 2031. Kolozsvár– Brussels: Kós Károly Akadémia – Wilfried Martens Center for European Studies.
  25. Kvale, S. 1996. Interviews: An Introduction to Qualitative Research Interviewing. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
  26. Lindemann, K. 2009. Ethnic Inequalities in Labour Market Entry in Estonia: The Changing Influence of Ethnicity and Language Proficiency on Labour Market Success. Mannheimer Zentrum für Europaische Sozialforschung. Working Paper 25, 1–18.
  27. Malhotra, N. K. 2008. Marketingkutatás. Budapest: Akadémiai Kiadó.
  28. Manea, L. D.–Virlanuta, F. O.–Muntean, M. C. 2019. Investigating the Causes of the Current Labor Shortage in Romania. In: The International Conference „The Risk in Contemporary Economy”. Galati: „Dunărea de Jos” University of Galaţi. Faculty of Economics, 44–52.
  29. Marginean, S. 2014. Youth unemployment in Romania: Post-crisis challenges. Procedia Economics and Finance 16, 613–620.
  30. Mocanu, C.–Zamfir, A. M. 2016. Jobs for Youth–Is There a Labour Market for Youth in Romania? SEA-Practical Application of Science 11, 401–407.
  31. Mungiu-Pupazan, M. C. 2019. The New Challenges Of The Labor Market. Annals Economy Series 6, 183–188.
  32. Péntek, J. 2009. Nyelvoktatássá válik a román nyelv tanítása, vagy megmarad eredménytelen „anyanyelv-pedagógiának”? In: Bálint, E.–Péntek, J. (szerk.) Oktatás: nyelvek határán. Közelkép és helyzetkép a romániai magyar oktatásról. Sepsiszentgyörgy: Anyanyelvápolók Erdélyi Szövetsége, 173–176.
  33. Pisica, S.–Vasile, V.–Dobre, A. M. 2015. Labour market for youth in Romania – a demographic and qualitative approach of their employability. Romanian Statistical Review 3, 118–129.
  34. Porter, L. W.–Steers, R. M. 1973. Organisational, work, and personal factors in employee turnover and absenteeism. Psychological Bulletin 80(2), 151–176.
  35. Sandu, D.–Toth, G.–Tudor, E. 2018. The nexus of motivation – experience in the migration process of young Romanians. Population, Space and Place 24(1), 1–16.
  36. Siskáné, Sz. B.–Halász, L.–Gál-Szabó, L. 2017. A magyar fiatalok erősödő kivándorlási szándékának kiváltó okai és jellemzői. Tér és Társadalom 31(4), 131–147.
  37. Sutton, G.–Griffin, M. A. 2000. Transition from student to practitioner: The role of expectations, values and personality. British Journal of Occupational Therapy 63(8), 380–388.
  38. Sutton, G.–Griffin, M. A. 2004. Integrating expectations, experiences, and psychological contract violations: A longitudinal study of new professionals. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 77(4), 493–514.
  39. Szanyi, F. E.–Susánszky, P. 2018. Iskolapadból a munkaerőpiacra – magyar fiatalok karrierpályaszakaszainak elemzése. In: Székely, L. (szerk.) Magyar fiatalok a Kárpátmedencében: Magyar Ifjúság Kutatás 2016. Budapest: Enigma 2001 Kiadó, 207–229.
  40. Szarowska, I. 2018. Importance of R&D expenditure for economic growth in selected CEE countries. E a M: Ekonomie a Management 21(4), 108–124.
  41. Székely, L. 2018. Magyar fiatalok a Kárpát-medencében – Magyar Ifjúság Kutatás 2016. Budapest: Kutatópont Kft.; Enigma 2001 Kiadó és Médiaszolgáltató Kft.
  42. Vasile, V.–Vasile, L. 2011. Youths on labour market. Features. Particularities. Promobility factors for graduates. Elements of a balanced policy for labour migration. Romanian Journal of Economics 32(1), 41–60.
  43. Veres, V. 2013. Népszámlálás 2011: A népességszám, foglalkozásszerkezet és iskolázottság nemzetiség szerinti megoszlása Romániában. Erdélyi Társadalom 11(2), 23–54.
  44. Veres, V. 2014. Társadalmi rétegződés és anyagi-jövedelmi különbségek Magyarországon és az erdélyi magyarság körében. Szociológiai Szemle 24(2), 4–46.
  45. Veres, V. 2017. A kolozsvári egyetemi hallgatók szakválasztási motivációi és munkavállalása nemzetiség és társadalmi háttér szerint. In: Változó kisebbség. Kárpátmedencei magyar fiatalok. Budapest: MTA TK Kisebbségkutató Intézet, 411–440.
  46. Wentling, R. M.–Waight, C. L. 2001. Initiatives that assist and barriers that hinder the successful transition of minority youth into the workplace in the USA. Journal of Education and Work 1, 71–89.

Authors

  • Csepeti Ádám
  • Bavlsík Richárd
  • Nagy Ákos

A szöveget automatikusan nyertük ki a PDF-ből; a táblázatok, ábrák és a pontos tördelés a lapszám PDF-változatában láthatók.